being cheap is expensive......

misfire

CGN frequent flyer
Rating - 100%
53   0   0
Location
GVRD
Just thought I'd tell you a story about my 686. Earlier this year I ran into some bad primer. Hot gases wound up blowing by the primer hole and ate up the hammer nose bushing on my 686. I knew that M D Charlton on the Island would be able to repair it but I sourced out a local 'smith because I didn't want to pay for shipping to/from the Island which would've added up to about 60 dollars both ways. I wound up taking it to the 'smith in Ladner because I read some posts saying that this fella was 'good'. 5 months later I get my 686 back and the following Saturday I take it to the range and.........light primer strikes. I call the 'smith and he says that it's my reloads. I go buy some factory ammo and the following weekend I get the same. I ask some of the people at the range if they've used this particular 'smith. Of the three people who have used him, none had good things to say about him. :eek: The following week I go to various Lower Mainland gunstores and starting making inquiries and the general consensus is that he runs hot and cold and I must've caught him during a 'cold spell'. :mad: Okay, no more messing around I call M D Charlton and make arrangements for them to repair my 686. Their turnaround time including shipping both ways was less than three weeks!!!! What did M D Charlton find? The hammer nose bushing was installed upside down which lead to the hammer nose being peened down. They replaced both the bushing and the hammer nose. Now, that's fast service. And I have no doubt that the revolver will work as it should this weekend.

I tried to save $60 bucks and wound up throwing away 150 bucks. :mad:
Yes, in the long run cheap is expensive......:redface:
 
Since you only live "across the pond" [Mainland BC vs Vancouver Island BC] from MD Charlton & not across the fricken country, I wonder what the heck you were thinkin' to begin with?

Plus, never heard of these "bad primers".... enlighten us on those? Did the mfg post a recall of them for the reasons you outlined? Or was there other "operator error" that contributed the the trouble with your 686??
 
Since you only live "across the pond" [Mainland BC vs Vancouver Island BC] from MD Charlton & not across the fricken country, I wonder what the heck you were thinkin' to begin with?

Plus, never heard of these "bad primers".... enlighten us on those? Did the mfg post a recall of them for the reasons you outlined? Or was there other "operator error" that contributed the the trouble with your 686??




The 'bad' primers were 30-40 year old CIL small pistol primers given to me by an 82 year friend on the Island. They were in great shape and none failed to detonate but.........pictures are worth a thousand words.

misfire.jpg


leakdamage.jpg


Okay, okay not only was I being cheap about the 'smith but my cheapness about getting 600 free primers started all this....:redface: :bangHead:
 
Wow, thanks for the post... I don't think I have any old CIL primers but I'll make sure to avoid them if I come across any for future reference.

Bummer they ate up your 686 like that. But yeah, since you only live across the pond from MD Charlton, you would've got faster turnaround than the route you went [guess you know that already].

We are lucky over here on Van Isle.... MD Charlton is only 10 min drive from my house. Was just in there on Friday picking up a new 1911 recoil spring....

Hope your 686 runs trouble free from here on in...................... ;)
 
Did you get a trigger job done too? (It would've been cheaper to get it done while it was there)

+1

When I sent my S&W Model 57 to MD Charlton for a rebarrel [installing a 6" barrel] I got him to do a "distiguished tune" on it while it was there. Worth every penny! :cool:
 
Don't forget what led to all this.....me being cheap. Hence no trigger job. Now that I think about it, I should have.....DOH!!!!! :redface: :slap:
 
Back
Top Bottom