Brand new Marlin 1895 GS

woodlotowner

CGN Ultra frequent flyer
Super GunNutz
Rating - 99.7%
591   2   2
I wasn't going to post this, but thought what the heck. With all the kerfuffle over Marlin quality control since being acquired by Cerberus (and now to be liquidated possibly in a political move by that holding company) I decided to share my most recent experience in the world of retail Marlin firearm sales.

I went to Ellwood Epps this week with a notion to look at some Marlin 1895 lever guns and make a go/no-go decision after having a look at some rifles. I started by looking at a GBL, but my buddy did not like the idea of a laminate stock so, to humour him, I asked to see the GS model (Guide Stainless) in stead. The first GS out of the box had a pretty gritty action and had a nickel size knot (with an actual void in the centre!) on the butt stock. The second one cycles nicely, but you could have shaved with the edges on the lever and it had some random but pad on it not even from the 1895 series (no sh$t). The third one had a blemish on the butt stock (not so bad that I would not have bought it perhaps), but it had sharp edges too. At this point (and I am not making this up) the fellow behind the counter (who was obviously more annoyed with Marlin than I was by this time) informs me that there is a limit of three for viewing new firearms (of the same kind) at their store. Well wouldn't you know the rear sling swivel stud was missing on this third rifle. I would have bought it if they had had one to provide me for home installation, but he went into the gunsmithing inner sanctum only to return a while later and inform me he had no luck locating one in stainless to match. Just when it looked as though I was going home with no Marlin, this fine fellow sighs and says he is going to make an exception and break out a fourth rifle for me to look at. I thank him very much and when he returns with the fourth box (and yes, you guessed it, not all the others had been previously unopened :) ) this Marlin is absolutely perfect. I take the gun home. The end.
 
I like my GS and if I had to find fault with it, the only difference, I would prefer a pistol grip butt stock.

Marlin1895GS45-70.jpg


With the power level of loads it's capable of handling and using some of the heavier bullets available, cast & jacketed, it can be a little hard on the fingers.
 
We had to go to a fifth GBL in the fall for my father, before one was found that was worth keeping. Misshappen extractors, total failures to cycle, internal parts looking like they were machined by a one eyed fifth grader working in bad light, front sights installed completely out of line, you name it. Then suddenly one was perfect.

Maybe Norinco should buy out Marlin and sort them out properly.

John Peterson - I totally agree with the pistol grip thing. There are three 45-70's in my family and the straight grips are sure harder on the hands!
 
I recently sold my plain 1895 Marlin and was immediately stricken with the urge to replace it with something a bit different. I, unlike others on this forum, prefer the straight stock on the Marlin (and on the BLR and BAR) since it just comes up better and points well for me. I understand about the fingers/hands. I shoot mild hand loads at the range and only sight in with hunting rounds prior to hunting season, so the number of more significant loads I fire in a year may total around 10. That's one of the reasons I like the 45-70, since it can be loaded from mild to wild. My new GS cycles snap caps perfectly and I intend to shoot it this weekend.....with mild loads already in the cupboard.

Mine has some kind of interesting tough matte finish on the stock, which I like, and is a very nice piece of walnut indeed. Your stock, however, is nicer, Johnn. :)
 
Finally got out to the range a couple of days ago (after a good cleaning and some polishing of internals in the interim). Cycles and shoots very well indeed. A keeper. I just need to polish the loading gate a bit to keep from lacerating my thumb every time I load it. What is the secret for pushing the last round all the way into the magazine?
 
Finally got out to the range a couple of days ago (after a good cleaning and some polishing of internals in the interim). Cycles and shoots very well indeed. A keeper. I just need to polish the loading gate a bit to keep from lacerating my thumb every time I load it. What is the secret for pushing the last round all the way into the magazine?

Use another shell to push with.
 
I bought a 1895 GS about 3 years ago. The loading gate bit my finger, the action felt rough and I couldn't hit the broad side of a barn with the factory iron sights. So I lightly polished the loading gate and action with some very fine grit sand paper, installed some XS ghost ring sights and swapped out the recoil pad for a little bigger one. Now I hardly leave home with out that gun. It almost always comes shooting with me. And in my first elk hunt I got a massive elk with it. There were some minor issues at the start but I worked them out and love that gun.

A friend just bought a new one last week and we sighted it in tonight. It shot great, looked great, and didn't pinch out fingers to load. The edges of the lever felt a little sharp but that's really quite minor.
 
With some of the adverse issues some have experienced, I've never had to deal with any of those issues or problems with mine, pictured in post #4. As I stated earlier, I would 'prefer' a pistol grip butt stock design but other than that, no problems. Admittedly:redface:, with a selection of cast and jacketed bullets, all I've really done is punched paper with it but hopefully it'll get 'field experience' before too long.
 
Back
Top Bottom