No, the first post by the OP details the intricacies of establishing antique status.
The post I quoted was about people getting persecuted/prosecuted.
The antique letter is voluntary. You are not required to get one if you don't want to. However, if you cannot prove the antique status of your gun, you may have it confiscated by police if they ever have reason to question it. In the past, I have had several customers come to me in a panic trying to get the antique letters they had lost because the police had confiscated their guns and charged them with everything from possession of a prohibited weapon, to trafficking. They did manage to prove their innocence in the end, but not after having to hire a lawyer at considerable expense. Nobody reimbursed them for that, or the headaches.
If you have a letter from the factory (or other proof) that your gun is an antique then you don't need the RCMP letter, of course. However, S&W only has shipping records, not manufacturing records, so it is quite likely that although your gun may have been made before 1898 the shipping ledger may say it was shipped after 1898. This, of course, would not prove its antique status. If the letter states that it was shipped before 1898 you are good, of course. It's your choice.
You may ask, why did the police have reason to look into the owner's possession of guns? In one case, it turned out to be an angry ex-girlfriend who wanted to make trouble for the guy, in another it was an angry tenant wanting to make trouble for his landlord. As you can see, it could happen to just about anyone. Whether or not the RCMP is out to "get us" is beyond this discussion. I highly doubt they are interested, and if JT gets his butt kicked out, the whole thing may be moot anyway.
Chris@oldgunscanada.com
www.oldgunscanada.com