Caribou populations back from the brink

bellero

CGN Ultra frequent flyer
Rating - 100%
121   0   0
Location
AB
When are they gonna realize that the caribou is a creature of cycles.
They also had the urge to throw in the high-powered rifles BS

By The Canadian Press, cbc.ca, Updated: August 22, 2011 11:19 AM

Caribou populations back from the brink


Two years ago scientists feared northern caribou were the new cod — once-teeming stocks of wildlife that had sustained entire cultures but were at the edge of collapse.

Now, as scientists from around the world gather in Yellowknife to compare notes, biologists are beginning to see signs that the worst is past for an animal so central to the Canadian imagination it's on the back of the quarter.

"Our situation overall is looking a lot brighter than it did two years ago," said Jan Adamczewski, a biologist with the government of the Northwest Territories. "Those of us concerned with management of these caribou herds are breathing just a little bit easier."

About 230 scientists from around the circumpolar world are meeting this week at a conference held once every four years on Arctic ungulates. They'll talk about muskox and reindeer, too, but the recent changes in caribou are sure to be a large part of the agenda.

In 2009, nine of Canada's 11 northern herds were considered to be in decline. Biologists estimated the Bathurst population on the central barrens had fallen to 32,000 from more than 120,000 in 2006.

That was a 75 per cent implosion, a loss of nearly 90,000 animals in only three years.

But since then both the Cape Bathurst and Bluenose East herds have stabilized. The Bluenose East herd is back up over 100,000 animals. Yukon's Porcupine herd is approaching 1980s levels.

And preliminary surveys in 2010 and 2011 of the Bathurst herd hint the free fall may have bottomed out.

"It kind of looks like maybe we've turned the corner there," said Adamczewski. "There's a very slight indication that the herd may be starting to increase."

Hunting restrictions key: biologist

Factors such as climate change, which upsets the delicate timing of northern ecosystems, and industrial development, which takes out sections of their range, have been blamed for some of the decline. But the two biggest factors were poor calf survival and hunting.

Good weather for the last couple of years has decreased calf mortality. And Adamczewski points out that all the recovering herds enjoy one factor in common — hunting restrictions.

"I think we're fairly clear that in the later stages of the decline, the harvest did start to accelerate the decline."

In a recently published paper, Adamczewski and three co-authors estimated the annual aboriginal harvest from the Bathurst herd alone was between 4,000 and 7,000 animals, mostly cows. Best estimates suggest that about 20 per cent of the cows were being killed every year, making it the most heavily hunted herd in the N.W.T.

"They were getting hammered," Adamczewski said.

But when hunting restrictions came in, the Dene could no longer take as many animals as they wanted. It was a huge problem because caribou is on the supper table several times a week in the North and hunting is a central part of what it means to be Dene.

Resistance to the region's first-ever hunting controls was strong. Several aboriginal groups took the territorial government to court. Outfitters brought their own legal action after losing their caribou tags.

But in the end, most of the caribou management boards — composed of government and aboriginal representatives — brought in restrictions.

"We know those were very tough decisions," Adamczewski said. "But there was a sense that they needed to be made."

Biologists don't blame hunting alone for the decline of the herds. Caribou populations have always fluctuated rapidly — with or without human intervention. Climate change is altering the habitat to which caribou have adapted.

And industrial development is nibbling away at their once-unimpeded range. Research to be presented at the conference suggests caribou avoid an area within a 14-kilometre radius of a mine or energy development.

But Adamczewski said an uncontrolled harvest, with hunters using modern high-powered rifles, snowmobiles and GPS systems, has become one of the biggest factors in the way of a recovery.

"When you look at how quickly things changed once harvest was either closed or severely restricted, the proof is right there."

http://news.ca.msn.com/top-stories/caribou-populations-back-from-the-brink-1
 
"When are they gonna realize that the caribou is a creature of cycles.
They also had the urge to throw in the high-powered rifles BS"

Brother, I'm with you on this one!
Iv'e been preaching for years that our (BC) woodland caribou, sometimes called mountain caribou, are cyclic in nature. I base my opinion on observations of some sixty, or so, years. I have stated this fact many times, that our caribou are syclic in nature, something that seems to not even be noticed by the biologists.
I even state this in my book, written about fifteen years ago and published about six years ago.
 
Northern Quebec Innus have stories in their oral tradition about caribous not being seen anywhere for more than 3 years. This was before the white man settled in North America.
 
There certainly is strong evidence that the caribou population works in cycles, probably in cycles of around 30 years.

One of the biggest problems, however, is that our landscape is changing much more rapidly, often as a result of human intervention. The habitat that existed during the last peak of the cycle will not be the same habitat when the cycle rolls around again, and I don't mean that in a good way.
 
That said, he is right that the locals were mashing the caribou and shooting a lot of cows. If you want to decrease a population of anything, kill the females. Sport hunters and resident hunters have been restricted to bulls only for at least 5 years and if you look at the GNWT Hunting Regulations synopsis you can see that the numbers of resident hunters over the last 10 years could only have had a minimal impact on Caribou population levels and their decline. From a high in 2000/2001 of less than 1200 resident hunters (maximum 5 tags either ### per hunter) to less than 100 in 2008/2009 (tags reduced to 2 bulls only) you can see that resident hunters have not been a factor in the decline.

http://www.enr.gov.nt.ca/_live/pages/wpPages/hunting_regulations.aspx
 
I think the woodland caribou of central BC have a cycle of more like 12 years, from low to high.
In the 1930s caribou reached a tremendous high. I have personally talked to old timers who lived in the Summit Lake area, just 30 miles north of Prince George. They all told of great numbers of caribou wintering in the Summit Lake area.
I also saw evidence to back this up. About 1949, when the Hart Highway, now # 97, was being built in the Summit Lake area, I walked through the pine covered sandridges just to the north. I found a considerable number of old shed caribou antlers, from about that period in time. Mice and many other forest creatures eat shed antlers, but they were still around, of course bleached snowy white and usually found in small pieces.
I think it is generally accepted that caribou reached a low in central BC in 1948. An old time bush pilot who made a hobby of counting caribou, said in the winter of 47-48, there was only one herd of 14 caribou in the entire Germansen Lake country, well known as a good area for caribou.
Then, in the fall of 1960, I photographed from the air, a herd of 32 caribou in the Pine Pass mountains, a hundred and twenty miles north of Prince George, an area usually not known for great numbers of caribou.
 
I think woodland caribou in some parts of BC (north-eastern) and here in Alberta are going to be nothing but a memory in the not so distant future. In regards to woodland caribou it has been proven many times that they will go to great lengths to avoid open disturbed areas....when they reach a cut block they will go all the way around rather than through it type of thing.

Now I know some folks are going to want to chime in that they have seen lots of caribou in cut blocks and on pipelines...well I have also witnessed that...but the bottom line is industrial development is likely going to be the demise of woodland caribou...

and to get to the original post...I don't always believe every word that I hear from bios and scientists...but do you really think that over 200 biologists/scientists are wrong...and a couple guys on an internet forum with (I'm guessing here) no back ground in wildlfie management are correct?...:rolleyes:
 
An aerial wolf kill would help...................Harold

It would surely save some caribou's lives but I am of the belief that if the habitat requirements are there than aniamls (whether they're big hooved creatures or gamebirds) will be able to cope. Killing off predators is merely prolonging the inevitable. (I am speaking to the areas I am familiar with...Alberta and NE BC).
 
It's an acknowledged fact that caribou populations go up and down, and have for centuries, without any influence by man.

In the northern portions of the provinces, the first stage of development is cut lines, making it easier for the prey species. It also provides a gateway for the mulies to move north with their nose bots that caribou are vulnerable to. Keep the deer out of caribou areas and watch the difference in population. I will be addressing this subject during the caribou conference this week, among other items.

The "interesting" point in Jan's interview was that he has finally targeted the blame for overharvesting here in the North, .....the natives were depleting the herds by 20% each year by shooting cows and calves. So why was all hunting by "non-natives" (only allowed to shoot bulls) cancelled for the future. Neither I nor any of our many clients have shot a cow in over 30 years, but we were blamed for the demise of caribou, entirely based on our ancestry!
 
Placing hunting restrictions on "resident", "sport", whatever tag you want to put on non-aboriginal hunters is a politically expedient "first step". Saw it in the '70s. The impact of hunting by this category of hunters was, and is, negligible. It is politically very, very difficult to even suggest that some Dene, Inuit, Inuvialuit hunters just might be wasting the resource.
 
The George River Herd (Quebec and Labrador) is also apparently on the rebound. Apparently the original assessment done 2 years ago was grossly miscalculated and underestimated. Rumour has it that non-residents will be able to get 1 bull tag starting next summer.
 
Up here, its just been one crock of $hit after another regarding the caribou. From the bogus "aerial/satelite COUNT" , to the bullying of the only people they can pick on........the non-native hunters up here. (Which can't be more than 700 -1000) who , on average, shot about 2 or 3 bulls, (maybe a cow if you weren't gonna be sharing!!) every year or two. Negligible affect on the herds.
The natives just balk at any talk of controlled harvest. They don't have to even report their kill, (which would help immensely in having the slightest inkling of whats ACTUALLY taken per year) Anything is just a suggestion regarding their harvesting.
I have personally witnessed SEVERAL times of the waste over the years with mass slaughter. Animals not fully harvested. Left alive but wounded. (and reported)
The Diamond mine trucks grind up the middle of their winter path each year, spooking, stressing and diverting them. Scattering them where they are easier prey for the wolves. (which are up in numbers, and there is an unofficial "cull" going on. They are issuing unlimited tags .....at least last season they did, 2 at a time, and paying 200 bucks per carcass , for -insert sarcasm- study)
Its funny how the other herds nearby suddenly plumped up. The bathhurst herd around here couldn't possibly have gotten "re-routed" by being more or less harassed or driven away by the trucks.(again insert sarcasm)
I believe that all herds eventually change areas to give the land a break , so to speak. Kinda like rotating crops. Its called a CYCLE.
The local herd will be back to good numbers in due time. When they are good and ready to come back to this area they will, right now the yukon and nunavut areas probably have better moss to eat. (and less diesel fumes)
 
I have personally talked to old timers who lived in the Summit Lake area, just 30 miles north of Prince George. They all told of great numbers of caribou wintering in the Summit Lake area.

Funny you mention that because I found a woodland caribou shed antler 25 or so years ago about 40 miles SW of Prince George but no one believes me when I tell them. I'd never seen one live.

Mind you, at that time it was unbroken bush and it's all clear cut now because of the pine beetle so I don't expect them to be there again for a long time.
 
Simply stating that they go in "cycles" does not remove you of all management responsibilities.

x2

There was a change observed in caribou herds so it was time to step back and have a look before things possibly got worse.

I can only imagine if caribou continued to decline...what would the internet crowd say then..."damn scientists and biologists...shoulda done something about that!"
 
The George River Herd (Quebec and Labrador) is also apparently on the rebound. Apparently the original assessment done 2 years ago was grossly miscalculated and underestimated. Rumour has it that non-residents will be able to get 1 bull tag starting next summer.

I'd be interested in your source for that. The hunt here for the 2011-12 season has been delayed.

NL government news release re Labrador caribou hunt

Edit: Checked with my high level contact at the NL Department of Environment & Conservation. He seems to think that rumour is without basis. In essence, the herd continues a drastic free fall, with 30% annual mortality and only 12% recruitment.
 
Last edited:
It hasn't changed, you can still purchase any number of wolf or wolverine tags, but they've doubled in cost to $20. Turn in a wolf carcass and you'll recieve a "thank you for supporting research" gift of $200! It must be for research as the NWT gov't says we don't have a predator problem.
Anyone else taking in the Caribou Symposium here in Yellowknife?
 
Back
Top Bottom