Right on GH, the scope should always be in the "up" position.
I've had this discussion many times, mostly wiht guys that ride far more often than me, and some of them are adamant that the scope down causes no harm. Like I said, I had trouble once on a horse trip 10 years ago, and ever since have wore the scope up. Fits better in my scabbard that way anyway.
I mount my rifle scabbard on the opposing side to that which I mount. The saddle has a natural tendency to slide on the mounting side. The extra weight of the rifle and scabbard leans it opposing. So when I mount up, it tends to straighten things up.
That is what I always understood to do as well, for the same reason. Although I generally mount any side I can get on because the damn horses i ride are invariably tall bastards.
I also place mine, butt back. Reason being the branches and crap can catch the buttstock while bushwacking.
My scabbard has a butt cover on it (as you can see in the pic- although there is no rifle in it in the picture) So I put it butt forward, but if it was open, I'd go butt back. In the pic, the end cap is kinda floppy, as it's just stuck on, but when a rifle is in it, it's quite snug, and all it takes is to pop a clip and you have acess.
Good to see you on horses though.

.
I'v always liked riding, and many of my neighbors have horses, so I try to get out a bit. I absolutely LOVE hunitng trips with horses, it's suh a fantastic way to get around...although I have wanted to shoot a horse more than once!
That pic is near the Prophet River, in northern BC, a good 3 days ride form anything that could be considered civilization. Great country.
Alot of people may think about "quick dismount" and access to rifle. That's only when indians com' a shootin'. Hunting!...you find a place to tie up and hoof it on foot, so it's not an issue
Only time I wanted quick acess was wiht that bear!
Sorry for the highjack, we can move on somepalce else need be.
It's a bear thread...Soon it will degrade into buckshot and spears, so we may as well talk scabbards and saddles.
