I asked a guy I bought a gun from, 40 year gun smith as well. Here is his answer:
? I have beechwood casey in a tube, I use with a Q tip.
But I also have liquid that I like , which is a darker blue, Outers gun blue, found that in Canadian tire.
When I still had the shop, I had a commercial blueing that you use in a tank, all most like a milt. black.
If I remember ,I may have used the Outers , and blended it with super fine steel wool