Comparing Optics.. What do you see?

Mystic Precision

CGN Ultra frequent flyer
Rating - 99.9%
1082   1   1
Location
Summerland, BC
In another post, I put up some points on how I compare scopes. Looked through a bunch and this test really separates the good from the poor. And many times, big price doesn't equate to great glass.

So have a read, look out your window and decide "What can you actually see?"

TESTING SCOPE RESOLUTION EASILY AT HOME....

What I use is a hand railing and chimney on homes over 1000yds away. There is no doubt that the are plenty of straight equally spaced lines and everyone understands what they are looking at.

But in comparing many scopes, my question is always... "what do you actually see?" I have yet to look through a scope that couldn't make out the shape of the chimney or the white lines of the rail.

Where most fail is being able to resolve the grid of these objects. To actually resolve and differentiate the detail that make up these patterns. Some will even bend the image so the objects are curved... which of course they are not.

Here is how the comparision typically go...

So many scopes will see the rectangle that is the chimney, with blotches of colour that are the bricks. Odds of seeing the grout line or anything beyond a multi colour rectangle are slim. If it is a scope, odds are you can see this.

Scopes that many call very good glass, will show the grid that is the grout lines but they are faint. Just a different colour blurry line. There will be the blotches which are the bricks, then a line, then a blotch. In this class, better scopes will give clear colour distinctions from brick to brick and within the brick itself.

Even better will clearly resolve the grout lines so they are sharp and distinct. You can see where they start, end and even if they do not line up with the next line. When highlighted with good light, each brick is clearly resolved in colour with the typical pattern easy to see.

Top tier glass under clear air and good lighting... you can see the texture and shadows in the grout line. Texture, lumps and bumps of the brick. This is the level that my scopes can see.

What do you see?

For top tier glass AND top tier coatings... you can see this even in moderate mirage. There are only 2 scopes I have looked through that can do this.

Jerry

PS Winter is the best time to try this. For many places, the air is very cold with near zero humidity. This drives out the moisture, dust that causes alot of optical distortion. Just don't open a window on a heated house and look out..... you are just looking through the flood of mirage that is the hot air escaping from your home.

Go outside, and put the scope on a tripod and view.
 
Was one of the 2 scopes that offered the best resolution a Sightron?

Edit - assume you mean in the best glass AND coatings category. Last example in my original post


Nope....

Jerry

PS - 2015 will bring out a new line from Sightron. I wonder what upgrades they are planning.. and no they will not tell me SH!T until SHOT
 
Last edited:
that's all great and dandy Jerry but one is still better to buy the scope that is going to work the best in the conditions they are going to shoot in......with that said on a hot august day we lined up a nightforce, March, Weaver T36 and a sightron SIII on a targets at 600 meters, all 4 scopes could see the target, however the march and nightforce picked up so much of the mirage that given the circumstances the Sightron had a clearer crisper image at the same magnification across the board, next time I want to watch the mirage infront of my target I'll go for the March, but for seeing the target I am shooting at I'll stay with the sightron or weaver which are about on par but the 30mm tube wins over on overcast and low light days and ranges.
 
yodave, very good points but I get dozens of questions on optics and we see lots of posts comparing this and that, I thought I would throw out this very simple test for anyone near houses to test.

You can of course use any object with linear and distinct pattern. Roof shingles are great too... you just need a grid with many lines in a geometric pattern you know.

Just looking at the outline of something can be very misleading cause our brains will figure out what the shape should be so we always "see" the shape.

But with geometric patterns, even though we know what it should be, can we actually see it?

That is where better glass earns its keep.

Glad the Sightrons worked out well for you in your test. I am surprised at your results but scopes do vary within the brand and from unit to unit.

Jerry
 
you need to add to that range to range.........

and what was the clearest scope on Monday may not win the cake on Tuesday, we are lucky here in that we get to shoot all year round, and the circuit takes us to 5 different well established ranges, all of which I am sure you used to shoot on with the exception of the long one in CR, however given all of the comparisons from a month to month bases the sightron SIII is the one that stands out, and that was endorsed by 3 or 4 guys using nightforce and the same using march, I don't get paid to endorse any products nor do I stand to gain financially from any endorsements or claims I may make, however the best bang for the buck scope on Vancouver Island is the sightron when one compares it in use 12 months of the year on various ranges and conditions, could be why there is more and more of them showing up here........
 
Back
Top Bottom