Copy vs Clone?

[pilot_dc]

So here's what might be a dumb question...

Anyone enlighten me on the difference between a copy and a clone. In some cases I've seen the terms used interchangeably, but I don't think that's right. I'm pretty sure when a company states that they make a copy they imply certain specific things. I've got a pretty good idea of what it means, but I'd like to hear an expert opinion.

Thanks,

DC

 

[IM_Lugger]

Not sure if there’s a set in stone definition, but IMO copy is a look alike; looks the same, but functions differently, while clone is exact ‘copy’ meaning that you can interchange parts…

 

[HKfan]

It depends on the copy, and depends on the clone.

Clone's are often licenced versions of the original design made by a different manufacturer with permission of the original designer. For example, Taurus makes the PT99 which is a clone of the Beretta 92 (debatable! :lol: ). Some HK rifles are liceced and made in Turkey. I guess the significant feature here is that there is an attempt to keep the gun as close to original as possible.

Copies generally refer to a design that has literally been copied with a view to altering the design, either without permission or after the patent ht has lapsed. Norinco 'clone' just about every handgun design under the sun with various success rates. A common one is copies of the CZ-75 which has come through in designs by Tanfoglio, Spinhx, and you guessed it, Norinco. Arguably the two last designers did not really do a great job improving the CZ-75 design, although I have been very impressed with the Tanfoglio / Witness. And of course, let;s not forget the 1911...

 

[Randy Carriere]

Unfortunately, some dealers don't quite know the difference either. I have a feg "clone" of a browning hp that has barrel problems. Can't just put a browning barrel in though as I got one of the feg hp COPIES, that looks like a browning hp on the outside, but totally different locking system(parts don't interchange).

 

[IM_Lugger]

For example, Taurus makes the PT99 which is a clone of the Beretta 92 (debatable! ).

well not reallya clone; you can't even interchange the mags... :wink: plus the safety is different too, frame vs. slide mounted.

 

[Deckard]

Various copies were attempted but they ended up being nothing but cyberorganic beings at best. With the introduction of clone technology, a new breed arose.

 

[richardoldfield]

A clone is a knock off and a licenced copy is made to factory specs under a licensing agreement with the orinal maker. A FIE TZ75 is a clone of a CZ75 but an FM High Power is a licenced copy of a Browning/FN High Power. Regards, Richard