I don’t know enough about the locations where you hunt, so I can only comment on my experiences hunting whitetails in the bush. Early season when the leaves are still on, or anytime it is clouded over, it gets dark in the woods much sooner than legal light. Before there is snow on the ground, it is very hard to put black crosshairs accurately on the vitals of a deer against a dark background, especially from an elevated tree stand. Also, my largest bucks have only come out in the last 10 minutes of legal light, after all the fawns and does filter through on the way to feed in the fields. This is why I prefer a red dot scope. At 35 yards or less, you don’t need any magnification, and a dimmable dot allows you to keep both eyes open and make a very accurate and ethical shot right up to legal light. Plus, they are smaller, and therefore easier to carry and tangle up less when walking in and hoisting up into the stand. The only downside is reliance on batteries, and forgetting to turn it off.....then the red dot is no dot, and you’re done. So I carry an extra battery, and always check the scope when unlocking the bow.
If you are hunting field edges or more open ground, or from a ground blind with some sky in the background, this may not matter to you.