CWD - How do you handle a positive animal

MiG25;20043796[B said:
]I don't think it's material if it is a virus, unconventional virus or protein prion the human stomach is going to destroy it.
[/B]
It is material that in order to infect "humanized" mice with CWD they inject it into their brains and even then the effects are variable. Same with Kuru and Chimps, Ferrets, etc they injected them with it, why not contaminate their food? Right, because that isn't how it spreads.

Trust the Science...

AHH enuf , a small sample of some back woods education ... good at typing
and that's about it
Want some CWD meat ..stand up
 
AHH enuf , a small sample of some back woods education ... good at typing
and that's about it
Want some CWD meat ..stand up

Being it on over, my stomach is 100 to 10,000 times more acidic than necessary to destroy any prions. Plus I am not a Deer and am not going to catch CWD any more than I caught Feline Leukemia from my cat.
 
jjohnwm,

You must work for Manitoba Resources Department, Yes? Or are some kind of biologist or government employee?

Lol, no, far from it. I'm just a guy who remembers reading much of the drivel you posted years ago, pre-COVID, regarding your little patch of Sask that you wanted to high-fence and then stock with grizzlies and all manner of ungulates. You were looking for business partners for this venture, droning on and on about how you would save the animals by treating them as your own personal property and charging for hunting. Your ideas weren't well-received by most of CGN back then. Are those posts still up? Deleted? Edited? I have no idea, and certainly don't care enough to check. Maybe some newer readers here have never seen them, and think I am being too harsh in my opinion. Again, don't care.


I mean, tell me at least I have a valid point here.

You make several valid points. Your presentation has improved immensely since your early loony-land-baron days, but sadly, while the past is the past...people remember, and many of us recall your diatribes and will inevitably have some predisposition towards not taking you seriously. As soon as I saw your username in this thread my initial thought was "Here it comes..." and, sure enough, you delivered.

There are many things the Manitoba government does with which I don't agree, many rules and regulations that I think are ineffective or even have a negative effect. That doesn't equate to agreeing with your...interesting views.

I will take my leave now, as this thread...worthwhile as it is...seems to be degenerating into a particularly well-populated trollfest.
 
I like it when they tell you it is positive after you have eaten 50% of it. Submitted in Nov and results back in March.
I never cut near the spinal cord or grind out the brain. 14 years later and still hunting strong.
Hunted 12 years in AB. Maybe something like the covid scare to add extra income to some provincial political supporter of the the residing gov..
 
Lol, no, far from it. I'm just a guy who remembers reading much of the drivel you posted years ago, pre-COVID, regarding your little patch of Sask that you wanted to high-fence and then stock with grizzlies and all manner of ungulates. You were looking for business partners for this venture, droning on and on about how you would save the animals by treating them as your own personal property and charging for hunting. Your ideas weren't well-received by most of CGN back then. Are those posts still up? Deleted? Edited? I have no idea, and certainly don't care enough to check. Maybe some newer readers here have never seen them, and think I am being too harsh in my opinion. Again, don't care.




You make several valid points. Your presentation has improved immensely since your early loony-land-baron days, but sadly, while the past is the past...people remember, and many of us recall your diatribes and will inevitably have some predisposition towards not taking you seriously. As soon as I saw your username in this thread my initial thought was "Here it comes..." and, sure enough, you delivered.

There are many things the Manitoba government does with which I don't agree, many rules and regulations that I think are ineffective or even have a negative effect. That doesn't equate to agreeing with your...interesting views.

I will take my leave now, as this thread...worthwhile as it is...seems to be degenerating into a particularly well-populated trollfest.

Where is the like button?
 
I like it when they tell you it is positive after you have eaten 50% of it. Submitted in Nov and results back in March.
I never cut near the spinal cord or grind out the brain. 14 years later and still hunting strong.
Hunted 12 years in AB. Maybe something like the covid scare to add extra income to some provincial political supporter of the the residing gov..

Sort of what baffled me - gov't directions at the time said to NOT get clear fluids, like spinal fluid, on things - then wanted you to cut off the head and submit it for testing. I never did figure out how to do that WITHOUT cutting across the spine at the atlas bone area ... I suppose one could "twist" off that head? - but the gov't instructions never said that.
 
They were so slow in 2022 at notifying the results of the CWD testing in Manitoba. They made it mandatory to submit samples, knew how many licences they usually issue and tags are filled, and yet they said they were surprised and overwhelmed by the number of samples. They had one single site in all of Winnipeg, out in Transcona. Out where I hunt, they have one location, only open till noon on Saturday. So I drove to Winker and found out that despite the Coop being open 7 days a week, they weren't accepting samples on Sunday. So much for the 48 hour deadline to turn in the sample.
 
They were so slow in 2022 at notifying the results of the CWD testing in Manitoba. They made it mandatory to submit samples, knew how many licences they usually issue and tags are filled, and yet they said they were surprised and overwhelmed by the number of samples. They had one single site in all of Winnipeg, out in Transcona. Out where I hunt, they have one location, only open till noon on Saturday. So I drove to Winker and found out that despite the Coop being open 7 days a week, they weren't accepting samples on Sunday. So much for the 48 hour deadline to turn in the sample.

I think you are describing collection points, not the labs that do the analysis. There was a collection point at Russell - at the Vet clinic - a big box with signs along the highway - was not clear to me how often that box was emptied, by whom or where the samples were taken for analysis.
 
I think you are describing collection points, not the labs that do the analysis. There was a collection point at Russell - at the Vet clinic - a big box with signs along the highway - was not clear to me how often that box was emptied, by whom or where the samples were taken for analysis.

Were you supposed to just throw the head in the box with the head tag attached? I'd have thought they wanted some information as to the date harvested and the exact location. The head tag doesn't show where it was harvested, and I'm pretty sure they were wanting that info. I'm not sure how self serve would have worked, but in 2022 they are talking about hours of operation of collection sites, not a drop box.
 
Were you supposed to just throw the head in the box with the head tag attached? I'd have thought they wanted some information as to the date harvested and the exact location. The head tag doesn't show where it was harvested, and I'm pretty sure they were wanting that info. I'm not sure how self serve would have worked, but in 2022 they are talking about hours of operation of collection sites, not a drop box.

You have to drop a pin and show where the animal was harvested when submitting a head for testing.
 
You have to drop a pin and show where the animal was harvested when submitting a head for testing.

That's what I thought. So I don't understand how a self serve drop box would work. Isn't there paperwork to fill out when you submit? None was provided to hunters in advance back in 2022.
 
The one maybe big problem is hunters shooting an animal out east and then bringing back home ...to the west

There's no safety check of positive or not when you drop off at bucther shop , that's WRONG ...
show proof before

CWD is spreading in the backs of trucks ... !!!!

I'm talking Alberta here

You have it backwards. CWD is in the West, and not in the East, at least, not past Quebec.

You're not really any better at this forum thing, despite your lengthy time out.
 
That's what I thought. So I don't understand how a self serve drop box would work. Isn't there paperwork to fill out when you submit? None was provided to hunters in advance back in 2022.

In Alberta you fill out a card and indicate the precise location, and date where the animal was harvested. With most folks carrying a GPS receiver these days that isn't really a big deal but even if you were not I think you could just take Geographic coordinates off a map and it would be just fine.
 
That's what I thought. So I don't understand how a self serve drop box would work. Isn't there paperwork to fill out when you submit? None was provided to hunters in advance back in 2022.

You could be correct - I have been in Manitoba since 2014 - I do not recall dropping of a head for testing here. I might be getting confused with the "Donate a Hide" thing that Sask Wildlife Federation was running. I doubt they want you standing at counter with "thawing" game head to do "paperwork" - as I recall, hide tag was affixed to ear - wrote down that number - head dropped outside in box (mine were usually in a garbage bag) - then go inside and use that number to do the "papers". Not actually "self-serve", except that part about dropping it in the box, outside.
 
Mig ended the debate guys,as long as you don't rub contaminated tissue in your eyes,nose,d@ck and just eat it your not get no prion disease.
 
Mig ended the debate guys,as long as you don't rub contaminated tissue in your eyes,nose,d@ck and just eat it your not get no prion disease.

Seeing as how no one has ever gotten CWD I'm the one on solid ground.

But hey, you Nervous Nellies can give up hunting and eat store bought meat and food from India and China and cantaloupe from fields Mexicans are pooping in and live forever...
 
You have it backwards. CWD is in the West, and not in the East, at least, not past Quebec.

You're not really any better at this forum thing, despite your lengthy time out.

I was refering to eastern Alberta ...read again pls

:)
 
Last edited:
Seeing as how no one has ever gotten CWD I'm the one on solid ground.

But hey, you Nervous Nellies can give up hunting and eat store bought meat and food from India and China and cantaloupe from fields Mexicans are pooping in and live forever...

You don't know that !!!!
 
Back
Top Bottom