Then the decesion 17 or 22Mag. I read good things about both. Your thoughts. Keep em coming!
I'm struggling with this question, and HAVE been for almost 2 years. I've had 2 HMRs for groundhog duty, and got rid of them because they can "just" do the job, with no margin for error. I ended-up with a .223 (that covers groundhog duty nicely) but kept my .22WMR (Savage 93FV) and took a number of big hogs with it before the .223 came in. Here is that rifle with a couple of biggies I shot this past summer;
Anyhow, it comes down to application/intended use really. I'm back to considering an HMR...again...because I plan on visiting your fair province for a gopher shoot this coming summer, and that's one application the HMR shines in for sure. Here in Ontario, the only HMR shooters I know are rabbit and squirrel hunters who like to challenge themselves with long (head) shots. Body shots with HMRs are usually too destructive on small game you plan on eating. A .22WMR is, in Ontario, a more versatile hunting round and shines in the 80-125 yard range. Trajectory starts to work against you past that. Some Albertans will chime-in I'm sure, but from my 2 buddies who hunt allot just outside of Calgary..it's .17HMR or .204/.223 for bigger varmints.
One cannot have too many .22lrs though!

I'd have to assume more gophers have fallen to .22lr than any other caliber. My friends have abandoned .22lr in favor of .17HMR for that business.
Good luck with your decision, I'm having no luck deciding whether or not to get an HMR, or introduce some gophers to my Ontario .22WMR rifle.
