When I attempted to form 43 brass from Win Mag cases, I saw it as a fun sideline project to get the rifle shooting and learn some new skills. However, after much frustration, I gave up and bought pre-formed cases.
Based on information I have acquired since then, I may try again in the future. For now though, I am happy and shooting it, and that's all that matters in the end.
As for my extractor, the piece that a broke off is the spring at the back to allow the extractor to close in behind tithe rim as the bolt is being locked. I'm going to add a bead of silicone or something to provide some spring back action as a stop gap measure until/if I find another complete extractor. Being as how the extractor is probably spring steel, plus the small size, I don't think it would be practical to weld a new piece on and reform it, then heat treat it again to get the spring action back.
I'm still searching for another, complete extractor, but I'm not putting a lot of effort into it, nor am I holding my breath.
I'll just enjoy loading and shooting it. I have cartridges that go "boom" and produce great clouds of smoke, but I need to play with paper patching to get the proper bullet diameter as well as get a load worked out that regulates to the sights. They are way off both wind age and elevation, from my limited accuracy testing so far.
I would like to eventually take the old girl and the spirit of my great grandfathers memory out deer hunting from time to time. If it can hold "minute of deer" @ 100yds, I'd be happy. I plan to take my other heirloom Mosin-Nagant SA marked M-91 out once in a while as well. That one shoots where I aim at least.