Do you have to clean the brass

jacky

CGN frequent flyer
Rating - 100%
40   0   0
Location
in the valley
I am just starting to get it together to reload for my pistol, 9mm mainly and was wondering if I have to clean or use a tumbler for the brass ?? Is that a must ???
 
No. It just makes em perty.

Unless you got tonnes and tonnes of gunk in them, then should be able to deprime them and soak them in warm soapy water to get the crud out.
 
Yes, it's a must. Trust me as someone who started out thinking it was optional. If you don't clean your cases, you will have dirty ammo. Firing dirty ammo pounds grit into the chamber of your gun, and decreases reliability.
 
I ahvent cleaned mine yet. Still need to get a tumbler. But the brass is wiped down during my prep. Havent had any issues yet, but I still want to get a tumbler or ultrasonic to clean them.
 
At first I just used a plastic coffee can and hot water with dish soap. Shake that thing for 5 minutes straight and it'll get all the gunk out. Make sure you're not mixing 9mm and .40 S&W (like I did) or the 9's will go inside the 40's and they'll never dry out.

I think you'll be impressed with the results, I almost convinced myself that I didn't need a tumbler the first time I did this.
 
It also depends on where you get your brass. If your brass has range pickups that have been out in a rain, then a tumbler is highly recommended to get rid of corrosion and crud. At the other extreme, if you are using once fired Winclean brass from an indoor range, then no cleaning is needed.
 
what caliber are you reloading in?
i go to an outdoor range , and i loose brass long before it would need a cleanup in a tumbler
 
"...brass from an indoor range, then no cleaning is needed...." Yes it is. That floor is covered with dust and assorted crud. Clean brass is essential. Shiney brass is not.
 
People had reloaded for maybe fifty years, maybe more, before anyone thought of tumbling the brass.
Common sense, wiping them clean, got them by just fine.
So, I don't see why it is a "Must."
 
A tumbler is optional but I don't suggest going that route...
dirty brass is will affect your accuracy,
be hard on your press (shellplate)
it wlll be hard on you dies

and cleaning does help you detect split cases
 
People had reloaded for maybe fifty years, maybe more, before anyone thought of tumbling the brass.
Common sense, wiping them clean, got them by just fine.
So, I don't see why it is a "Must."

Because 50 years ago people weren't loading shooting/loading 1000-2000 rounds a week.. Guns were built by hand and had larger tolerances..
 
IMO, it's not one of those absolutely necessary things, but highly recommended. I find that cases seem to size better, look better, and I can find flaws easier when cases are cleaned. I clean them both before, and after sizing; the first time around to scrub the powder residue off, and the second time around to clean the lubricant off. I suspect that getting the powder off makes the sizing die last longer, and getting the lubricant off makes less case head thrust.
Others may disagree, but "OH well!"
Mike
 
I tumble so I can see cracks and flaws easier, easier on my dies, makes the brass purdy and so I don't look like I'm loading 100 year old ammo when I go to the range.
 
Yes, it's a must. Trust me as someone who started out thinking it was optional. If you don't clean your cases, you will have dirty ammo. Firing dirty ammo pounds grit into the chamber of your gun, and decreases reliability.

I agree with what Canuck223 said if you want clean brass (inside and out)
All you do is throw the brass in the tumbler for 3-4 hrs .....clean brass no easier way of doing it.
 
A quote:Because 50 years ago people weren't loading shooting/loading 1000-2000 rounds a week.. Guns were built by hand and had larger tolerances..
__________________


Shucks, here I thought the pre 64 Model 70s, et al, had pretty darn precise clearances!
 
Last edited:
Birchwood Casey makes a liquid case cleaner that can be used as an alternative to tumbling. It doesn't make your cases bright and shiny, but it's good enough to remove grit so you don't scratch your dies.
 
the tumbler is the last thing I have bought for getting into reloading.
I bought the cabelas starter kit and let me tell you that for under 100$ taxes and shipping included, you get an amazing kit. They use Berry's model 400 tumbler (only difference is the colour and cabela's tag). You get a sifter, polish, big bag of media.
I clean brass every firing now (unlike before, I cleaned with steel wool by hand when dirt was too obvious) and found that a used sheet of bounce keeps the media cleaner (if you're just that cheap to think media is too expensive, cause my media is about 20 cleanings old and I havent changed it yet)
 
Back
Top Bottom