Does it count when??

jtoews80

CGN Regular
Rating - 100%
114   0   0
Just a question.

The biggest buck I have ever shot, was a put down, a mercy kill. Personally, I don't count this as my trophy. I've kept the rack, but never scored it. The worst thing about it, is he was hit on private land by a poacher shooting off the road.
It was a massive 5X5 on my dad's alfalfa field with a few does on Dec 7/05. He is obviously hit, severe limp on left front quarter and although trying to mount a doe in the field falling down.

My younger brother and I were checking some scraps we had thrown out on a back field from butchering our deer that year for coyotes and seen this wounded buck.
So, we stopped, I got out and took a little bit hurried shot at him at 200 yds or so as the buck and does bolted when we stopped. I missed him cleanly.

So, we got back into the truck and went off the field onto and around onto access road that runs along the quarter. This took about 5 minutes, and we located this wounded buck maybe 200 yds from the original point we seen him at the first time, but had to drive around to see him.

This is one of the reasons it wasn't really MY trophy. A healthy buck this size would have run at least a half mile, not stopped at let me get out of the truck and put a round into him which finally anchored him. The truck obviously is the other reason, a bit of a mechanical advantage.

When we cleaned him, we found the wound to the front left leg, looked to be somewhere around .30 caliber(hard to tell with the infection in the local), went into the high leg and took out a bit of the sternum, but not enough to bring him down. There was about a liter or liter and a half of geenish-white pus in the soft tissue around the wound and the whole carcass smelt fevered or off. We ended up hanging it for a few days to see if the dog would touch the gut pile or the whole thing was a loss. The dog wouldn't eat it, nor the coyotes when we threw it out back, the buzzards ended up eating it.

What is your take on this??
 
Last edited:
A healthy buck that is with a hot doe likely would of let you drive up to and kill him with a claw hammer....If he was trying to mount a doe he wasn't worried about anything you were doing.


Were you legal to shoot this buck? He was in season? You had a tag and did it legally?

If so, thats your buck, and your trophy.
 
I think you did the right thing, he was coyote bait anyways. Hopefully he knocked up a couple does before he got ended, sounds like good genes in that one.

Had a buddy take what he thought was a doe that came limping through my lot a few years ago. We had no doe tags left but he said he couldn't let it live the way it was hurt. Ended up being a spike buck that had his ears up so we got to legally tag it anyways.
 
Humane killing is part of hunting, farming, and just being human. If an animal is suffering, we put it down. A nice looking rack looks good on the side of the shop or barn. It doesn't take ten minutes to do a quick score. People are impressed that there are nice deer out there and that someone has evidence to prove it. I don't see what the problem is.
 
Humane killing is part of hunting, farming, and just being human. If an animal is suffering, we put it down. A nice looking rack looks good on the side of the shop or barn. It doesn't take ten minutes to do a quick score. People are impressed that there are nice deer out there and that someone has evidence to prove it. I don't see what the problem is.

Well said !!
 
Kind of hard looking at your trophy deer when knowing the circumstances...but really nobody has to know. I'd love to know how many book deer and other big game heads entered in local "big buck nights" were taken under iffy circumstances. Personally I'd put the head/rack on the wall and not worry about it.
 
I'd probably mount it because it was an exceptional buck. It's up to you how you feel about it, but look at it this way-

Hunters take advantage of all sorts of circumstances- natural and unnatural- to help them bag thier game. Not eery trophy is bagged by a hunter silently slipping through thick timber after hiking 16 hours to the top of a mountain.:p
 
My buddy shot a 6 pointer that had its lower jaw blown off...the wound was about a week old and the deer looked frail and exhausted...My buddy was planning on taking a doe, as there were some nice ones on the property, but once he saw this guy he put him out of his misery.

The rack, though small, is now a nice euro mount on the wall of his den. It might not be how you wanted it to turn out, but you did the right thing, and you put in the effort to get him. Its your trophy!
 
I know exactly what you are saying. It almost feels like cheating because you didn't take the animal during what you consider to be an ideal hunt/harvest of the animal. It's like someone leaving a $20.00 bill at the ATM. It's yours but it ain't.

I know that under the circumstances most ethical hunters would terminate the suffering of the animal. You actually could have gotten a new tag from the CO's if it is unfit for human consumption.

At the very least you can admire the score and size of the animal even if it doesn't sit right with ya. Just won't be the big buck story that we all would like to have after harvesting a trophy animal.

Anyways, don't beat yourself up and keep your stick on the ice!!
 
A hunting trophy isn't quite like a bowling trophy where you "win" according to rigid set of rules.

It's more like a momento of an event. You don't control the event, but participated in and wrote the ending. What happened, happened. If anything, there's more story behind your momento than most. What's wrong with that?
 
i wouldnt read so much into it. Think of his rack as a reward for doing the right thing. You should be proud of your actions and you will think of that day every time you look at his rack.
 
Had to dig thro an old aux drive to find them. The rack is sitting in a shed, I'll have to dig it out and get it scored. If you look closely at this rack, there is alot of mass, even the brow tines are about an inch or more wide and the mains are huge.

Picture002.jpg


Picture004.jpg


Picture003.jpg


Picture006.jpg
 
That is your trophy and display it proudly. To me, a mount (either full or euro) is a tribute to the deer, not the hunter, kept as a reminder of days gone by and of natures wonder.

Damn... that came off a lot cornier that it was supposed to, but I think some of you will get me meaning.

P.S. plus it is a huge rack, so WTF not... right?
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom