Personally buckshot works to my advantage when I'm gun hunting, in the unique situations I'm hunting in. I have a good killing pattern to 40 yards, great pattern to 35 yards, excellent pattern at 30, and devastating pattern below that. The max shot I can take on my stand is 40 yards which happens to be the rounds and my personal limit. I've patterned many brands of slugs at the exact same ranges and beyond out of my gun, and they shot no more accurately at 40 yards, and at that range they were no more consistent than buckshot. This is because of the shotgun I have (SX3) has a large front bead that makes an accurate shot with a single projectile difficult at any range over 30-35 yards. If I have a deer that comes in at a slow trot at 40 yards, I would never feel comfortable with this setup shooting slugs at that range, its just too high a risk for bad shot placement. Surprisingly I had that EXACT situation happen last year on the stand opening morning when I had my first buck and also buck of a lifetime come within 40 yards at a steady slow trot. ONE shot with buckshot and he hit the dirt and stayed there at 40 yards. If I were using slugs I would have let him walk as I wouldn't be comfortable with the shot and it would have been the greatest hunting regret of my life.
Thats just me personally though. I've done my due diligence and try to do my hunting as humane as I can. I've patterned many brands of loads with many chokes and have done the same with slugs. I would not take any shot no matter what I was using if I knew it wasn't going to end well. I'm only using it ethically, I can promise anyone that. In the right hands its a great load with great potential, in the wrong its a disaster and absolute embarrassment to ethical hunting.
I do understand both sides fully, and completely understand its terrible joke of a reputation. It does not belong in the hands of irresponsible hunters who can't judge distances correctly or cannot control their nerves when they see a deer. If you have the ability to take a breath and line up a shot at a known distance at a range thats acceptable with its pattern, its good. Otherwise slugs are the way to go, hands down.