Eley UK reports that at their test range they do 10 shots in the first round, and 30 shots in the second round. Is there any particular reason you only do 20?
I believe the reason Dave asked about testing Match is you still benefit from testing different lots, despite Match being Tenex that was sub-par. But Match is a good deal cheaper. You benefit from lot testing any brand/line, for that matter, even the cheap stuff as you go downward in the lineup. I can understand if you guys and/or Eley only want to do it with Tenex. But I can also understand why a shooter would want to do it with any in the line. While Match, or Club, or even Sport, is not capable of the same accuracy/consistency as Tenex is there is still a benefit to lot testing. You'll still be able to find something that your barrel likes more than the next one, even if it is cheaper stuff that will never shoot as well as Tenex does round after round.
Is that $300 price because one of your employees is taking the time to do the testing? If I'm there and would like to do it myself, after you've set it up in the rig, could I? And would the price remain the same? Thanks.
When Eley trained us on this process, it was decided to operate with a total of 30 rounds (whereas Eley run 40 rounds) simply due to lot number limitations. The Eley factory has a great deal larger supply of this ammo than we do. To ensure we are able to meet the quantity minimum for Eley's testing program, 30 rounds total will provide enough data for the test to be effective.
We can test Match (as we should have enough lot numbers to run the test). Eley does not offer this at any of their test facilities (nor will they test the other lines - Sport, Club, Action, Force, etc.)
Completely agree on testing the other lines. We are looking at options to offer this service in the future, as there are many shooters that would opt for the best Eley lot of ammo possible in their rifle. A few of us here would like to run this test with our CRPS setups. However, we are limited on which rifles we can test (due to the fixtures required for each rifle).
The cost is based on several factors: labour, testing ammo, return freight is included in the cost, range costs, etc. If you are local and are looking to have your firearm tested, you are welcomed to be here to watch the process. To ensure a consistency test, our tech will run the program and shoot.
Shooters who are interested in less expensive varieties of ammo may understandably balk at a $300 testing fee. The testing fee would represent a significant portion of the price of a case of Eley Club or Sport.
It is still possible to test different lots of the less costly ammo without the testing facility vise and tunnel. A shooter would have to buy ammo from as many lots as possible, say a box or two of each lot, enough so that a dealer could ship you a brick of the ammo with four or five different lots -- more if possible. Go to the range on a very calm day and test the different lots by shooting ten five-shot-groups of each different lot. Pick the lot that produces the most consistently small groups and buy more of it. The brick's worth of testing ammo will have cost much less than the testing fee at Korth.
All the above requires that the dealer has enough lots to make testing worthwhile. It also requires that range visits can coincide with calm conditions and it might take more than one trip to the range. It also requires that testing results are sufficiently reliable. The last two necessities are probably the easiest parts. It might be necessary to get ammo from more than one dealer, in which case it is necessary to make sure that all the ammo being tested is available in quantity so that more of it -- a case or more -- can be ordered after all the testing.
For someone interested in shooting the best ammo that can be found, perhaps the testing facility "deal" can be a very good one. (For someone who can't make it to the Okotoks testing facility, apparently they can ship their barreled action to Korth and they will do the rest.) If you wanted to do the testing by yourself the old fashioned way at your local range, by the time you find a dealer (or dealers) with several lots of Tenex to test, getting a brick of a number of different lots will cost at least $200, more when taxes and shipping is included.
I don't know if Korth charges for each round fired during testing. It would be a understandable if they did. But that would be a small price to pay to have a good number of different lots of ammo tested in a facility with all the equipment that they have. I wouldn't bother with it for less expensive ammo, but to get reliable results quickly and efficiently for some of the best ammo available, without the time and trouble of testing it yourself, the testing facility sounds like a good deal -- especially when the testing fee is waived with the purchase of the Tenex ammo at the end of the testing. After all that is the goal -- finding the best ammo for your rifle.
There was a thread by one of the first shooters to avail himself of the Korth Eley testing facility last year.
The fee will scare of some shooters. At this time, we have fixtures to test high end competition rifles (Anschutz, Walther, Feinwerkbau, Pardini, etc). The initial purpose of this testing is for the top level of competition. To date, we have tested firearms for two Olympians, and many Internationally ranked ISSF shooters.
Our goal is to add fixtures to open the options up to commercially available rifles (Ruger, Savage, CZ, VOODOO, etc.), and test the more common ammo - Force, Contact, Sport, Club, etc. The cost to perform this test will not decrease by much, as the bulk of the fixed costs are the same whether we test Tenex or Sport.
Folks can certainly test on their own. A few of our dealers have offered kits where you receive a box of each sku, comprising a brick (1 x Match, 1 x Force, 1 x Sport, etc.). This is a great way to start. However, home testing on a bench, shooting outside will not replace the level of consistency and accuracy of testing provided by the Eley program. For those of us with sporting rifles, home testing is the best we have available to us for now.
Thanks for the great comments - let's keep the discussion going!
KGL