I'll preface this with saying I load pistol and rifle (my reference for straight and bottleneck cases in this thread), everything from plinking to precision ammo on an RCBS Rockchucker, Dillon 550 with a case feeder and a Dillon 650 with a case feeder. I've owned and enjoyed a Hornady Look n' Load as well.
The Rockchucker is dedicated to doing precision handloads with competition quality dies from predominantly Forster, RCBS, Redding. It does some load development and odd calibers that don't see a lot of use like milsurps in 7.5x55, 6.5x55, etc.
The Dillons do mostly pistol and some higher volume rifle calibers like .308 and .223 on most dies under the sun, but for pistol I like the Dillon dies.
I started with a Rockchucker and then progressed to the 550, and then 650 when I was competing with pistol in IDPA and IPSC.
Here are my recommendations:
- As already stated, it is really dependent on what you want to do, and how you shoot (volumes, expectations of your ammo).
- Skip the Lee and Lyman junk - at least for now (both make some decent stuff, like the Lee factory crimp dies), but get your feet wet with better brand stuff first. Bear in mind that people that recommend them, or have only known these brands often don't know what they don't know. Likewise with folks that have and only have used a single stage).
- If you compete, and are a heavy volume shooter, the 650 is an awesome setup, and can easily be set up to do pistol and rifle.
- If you don't compete, but don't like burning time at the reloading bench either, the 550 is great too and can do both rifle and pistol. It doesn't auto advance like the 650 and the addition of the case feeder is separate. (these attributes can actually be an advantage, albeit slower when you are trying to churn out ammo). It is cheaper than the 650, and you can pretty much do everything on it, even using it as a single or with modified stages (like one would do with bottle neck cases).
- You could add the Hornady Lock n' Load as a good substitute for either the 550 or 650.
- Go to the Brian Ennos forums and surf through the recommendations. (https:_//brianenos.com/dillon-2/#which_