I had been hunting consistantly everything for years with my bolt action .30-06. Recently, I decided to go back to my roots where I started out with a lever .30-30 for deer. There's just something special about these rifles that brings you back to when you didn't need the latest wizzbang and horendous muzzleblast to get the job done.
For an affordable and reliable lever gun, it's difficult to beat a Marlin 336 in 30-30. It has low kick, comes standard with iron sights, easy scope mounting, short and compact. Plus, lately with Hornady's Leverevelution ammo, a fine performer to 200 yards.
If you can find a Winchester AE 30-30 (AE = angle eject for easy scope mounting) at a decent price (just the finding one can be very challenging) in decent condition, it would be a great rifle too. I've tried to find one in my price range, but found that used Marlins were less expensive and much easier to find.
In my opinion, plastic bolt rifles are but a simple tool that are a dime a dozen and have no character, no history, and no soul. They're the ones that get traded over and over as a "starting" rifle because owners grow quickly tired of them. Do they work? Sure they do, but that's where it starts and stops.