GSG or SIG?

KDX

CGN Ultra frequent flyer
Rating - 100%
97   0   1
I'm thinking of buying a .22cal based on the 1911 platform. Which one of these is the better one to buy or are there other options out there?
 
I'm thinking of buying a .22cal based on the 1911 platform. Which one of these is the better one to buy or are there other options out there?

I tried the Chiappa and was extremely dissapointed... The heaviest trigger I have seen in a long time.

There are also some Colt out there, made by Walther
 
I love my GSG. But the barrel bushing did break, my fault. I got a new one right away from the Blue Line (I think). The finish is cheap, but the gun inexpensive.
 
I'm thinking of buying a .22cal based on the 1911 platform. Which one of these is the better one to buy or are there other options out there?

Can only comment on the GSG, and it will most likely have ONE issue. I have owned a GSG in the past, and another range bro also has one with lots of rounds through it, so I speak from experience.

The Guide Rod will most likely break on ya, it's just aluminum and simply not up to the task. Mine sheared at the base, and my bro's has also sheared in the same location.
It is a weak link on the pistol. It just is.
It's aluminum and should be steel to match the rest of the pistol ;)

And it was not us installing it incorrectly either, we both have experience.

Secondly, you'll have to get a replacement form Blue Line. Myself and my buddy waited 1 month + to get it (his happened 6 months after mine btw). I'm not busting balls but neither of us will do business with them again.
If they say one week it means 1+ month. If they say they mailed out 3 to you already when you call after 3 weeks, that translates into they have JUST shipped one out after your call.
My bro had the EXACT same experience. We laugh about it. (btw, neither of our other 2 previously mailed out replacements ever turned up :rolleyes:)

Better than North Silva, but not by much, if that makes any sense to you ;)
(I won't even comment on my PARA/North Silva experience. You'd be better off getting gang banged by your local pant sagging thugs at the corner store. TOTAL ineptitude)

So there you have it :confused: All true too.

In conclusion, the GSG is a great piece, and feels/shoots SOOO good, but if you decide to get one, get a back up guide rod or two asap. Plus be willing to deal with a supplier who obviously does not stock parts.
 
Thanks for the posts and info. I just read on Rimfire Central that the GSG and SIG are identical.
 
GSG you will get excellent service from Blue Line. Sig, who knows. It's the same gun except the name is different and you pay about $100 more for the Sig name.
 
Can only comment on the GSG, and it will most likely have ONE issue. I have owned a GSG in the past, and another range bro also has one with lots of rounds through it, so I speak from experience.

The Guide Rod will most likely break on ya, it's just aluminum and simply not up to the task. Mine sheared at the base, and my bro's has also sheared in the same location.
It is a weak link on the pistol. It just is.
It's aluminum and should be steel to match the rest of the pistol ;)

And it was not us installing it incorrectly either, we both have experience.

Secondly, you'll have to get a replacement form Blue Line. Myself and my buddy waited 1 month + to get it (his happened 6 months after mine btw). I'm not busting balls but neither of us will do business with them again.
If they say one week it means 1+ month. If they say they mailed out 3 to you already when you call after 3 weeks, that translates into they have JUST shipped one out after your call.
My bro had the EXACT same experience. We laugh about it. (btw, neither of our other 2 previously mailed out replacements ever turned up :rolleyes:)

Better than North Silva, but not by much, if that makes any sense to you ;)
(I won't even comment on my PARA/North Silva experience. You'd be better off getting gang banged by your local pant sagging thugs at the corner store. TOTAL ineptitude)

So there you have it :confused: All true too.

In conclusion, the GSG is a great piece, and feels/shoots SOOO good, but if you decide to get one, get a back up guide rod or two asap. Plus be willing to deal with a supplier who obviously does not stock parts.

I do want to apologize for any past dealings with regards to any GSG products or any service from Blue Line.

I have been with the company several months now and our supply of spare parts from Germany has increased in this time.

We do have a full stock on the majority of spare parts which have been needed for the GSG 1911, I apologize again for any delays caused by stock in the past.

I would like to hear more about your experience and see if there is anything we can do to restore your thoughts on the services from Blue Line. Please email me at rpatterson@blueline-activities.com. I look forward to hearing from you soon.

If anyone has any questions or concerns with regards to any issues with any GSG products or any services provided by Blue Line please feel free to contact me directly.

We are a growing company and as with all companies there have been some growing pains in the past, I cannot comment on issues which have happened in the past but I can work on ensuring that issues like this do not happen again in the future.

Best regards,

Ryan Patterson
National Director of Operations
Blue Line Activities Ltd.
rpatterson@blueline-activities.com
 
I do want to apologize for any past dealings with regards to any GSG products or any service from Blue Line.

I have been with the company several months now and our supply of spare parts from Germany has increased in this time.

We do have a full stock on the majority of spare parts which have been needed for the GSG 1911, I apologize again for any delays caused by stock in the past.

I would like to hear more about your experience and see if there is anything we can do to restore your thoughts on the services from Blue Line. Please email me at rpatterson@blueline-activities.com. I look forward to hearing from you soon.

If anyone has any questions or concerns with regards to any issues with any GSG products or any services provided by Blue Line please feel free to contact me directly.

We are a growing company and as with all companies there have been some growing pains in the past, I cannot comment on issues which have happened in the past but I can work on ensuring that issues like this do not happen again in the future.

Best regards,

Ryan Patterson
National Director of Operations
Blue Line Activities Ltd.
rpatterson@blueline-activities.com

Good on you to try and make things right.

I have a lot of respect for companies that go the distance to make thing right for their customers.
 
I do want to apologize for any past dealings with regards to any GSG products or any service from Blue Line.

I have been with the company several months now and our supply of spare parts from Germany has increased in this time.

We do have a full stock on the majority of spare parts which have been needed for the GSG 1911, I apologize again for any delays caused by stock in the past.

I would like to hear more about your experience and see if there is anything we can do to restore your thoughts on the services from Blue Line. Please email me at rpatterson@blueline-activities.com. I look forward to hearing from you soon.

If anyone has any questions or concerns with regards to any issues with any GSG products or any services provided by Blue Line please feel free to contact me directly.

We are a growing company and as with all companies there have been some growing pains in the past, I cannot comment on issues which have happened in the past but I can work on ensuring that issues like this do not happen again in the future.

Best regards,

Ryan Patterson
National Director of Operations
Blue Line Activities Ltd.
rpatterson@blueline-activities.com

The response is appreciated. Glad to hear you`re listening. Will pass on to my shooting partner.

Being a business owner myself, I`ll chalk it up to a misunderstanding.

Take care and best of luck in the future.
 
I have one thing to say about BlueLine customer service. Absolutely excellent!
My GSG was having problems with the barrel threads after 3000 rounds.

I called to simply order a new barrel but they went beyond! Ryan Patterson warranted my barrel no questions asked. I sent them the pistol so they could take a look at the issue and within 3 weeks the pistol was back in my hands and I live in Nova Scotia.

I like to shop local but with customer service like this, my next firearm purchases will be with Blueline. Don't tell me they have bad customer service, because they treated me like a king.
Blueline stands by their products and I will do business with them again!

As for the GSG 1911, If mine falls apart tomorrow, I will buy another! Great gun


Juteau
 
I do want to apologize for any past dealings with regards to any GSG products or any service from Blue Line.

I have been with the company several months now and our supply of spare parts from Germany has increased in this time.

We do have a full stock on the majority of spare parts which have been needed for the GSG 1911, I apologize again for any delays caused by stock in the past.

I would like to hear more about your experience and see if there is anything we can do to restore your thoughts on the services from Blue Line. Please email me at rpatterson@blueline-activities.com. I look forward to hearing from you soon.

If anyone has any questions or concerns with regards to any issues with any GSG products or any services provided by Blue Line please feel free to contact me directly.

We are a growing company and as with all companies there have been some growing pains in the past, I cannot comment on issues which have happened in the past but I can work on ensuring that issues like this do not happen again in the future.

Best regards,

Ryan Patterson
National Director of Operations
Blue Line Activities Ltd.
rpatterson@blueline-activities.com

I bought my GSG from a dealer (not Blue-line).
When I asked GSG about a replacement washer for one I lost.
It was in my hands, no questions asked, a few days later.

When I expressed my concern about hearing about so many guide rods breaking, they sent me a kit. Again, no questions asked.

I recommend them 100% to anyone who has or is thinking of getting a 22LR 1911

Some fellow shooters at the club were asking. All I had to tell them is post on CGN (anywhere.......... Scott or Blue-line will see it and respond immediately.) A few days later they were thanking ME for the tip (and the excellent service they received.)

Different folks??????????
 
As far as the gun goes, one of my favourite. I have about 7000 rounds through it and it gets better every time I go to the range. My guide rod did break at about the 3000 round mark and as mentioned above, it took a LONG time to get a replacement (almost 2 months). I was also told that they had shipped it and CP had lost it. The first time, maybe...but 3 times???

Ryan, I'm glad that you posted here and I hope your supply troubles are over. I wouldn't have minded if you guys had just told me you didn't have any in stock but to #### me around for months is unacceptable.
 
As far as the gun goes, one of my favourite. I have about 7000 rounds through it and it gets better every time I go to the range. My guide rod did break at about the 3000 round mark and as mentioned above, it took a LONG time to get a replacement (almost 2 months). I was also told that they had shipped it and CP had lost it. The first time, maybe...but 3 times???

Ryan, I'm glad that you posted here and I hope your supply troubles are over. I wouldn't have minded if you guys had just told me you didn't have any in stock but to #### me around for months is unacceptable.

Hello Wherermykeys,

I do want to apologize for any problems with your prior dealings with Blue Line. You should have been informed if there was any problems with inventory when you originally spoke to the representative. Please be assured that this will not happen again and if there is anything I can be of assistance with please let me know. I am very glad to hear you are happy with your GSG 1911, we look forward to bringing other equally as enjoyable products to the marketplace in the very near future.

Best regards,
Ryan Patterson
National Director of Operations
Blue Line Activities Ltd.
 
Back
Top Bottom