Help me pick a do it all Ontario hunting rifle.

So now I am looking at the X-Bolt in either .270 or 6.5 creedmoor. I really prefer the aesthetics of wood but understand a synthetic stock is more practical. I just don't want one that's cheap feeling. Decisions, decisions.

As an owner of two x bolts wearing synthetic stocks, one has the “dura touch”, the other does not, I would say they are not a cheap feeling synthetic stock. I’ve also owned savage axis’ and Ruger American rifles, those feel cheap. I absolutely love the way the x bolt stock fits me, better than any other factory gun I’ve shouldered, which is most of them. The palm swell fits my large hands nicely. I also love where the safety is on x bolts (where it should be!!!). One gripe, the triggers don’t adjust as low as browning says they will. They are however still a fantastic trigger.

Between 270 and 6.5 creedmoor, I prefer the creedmoor. With good shot placement, within practical hunting ranges they’ll both level big game. Use the right bullet for the job, practice practice practice, put meat in the freezer. 270 is a great cartridge, move velocity and energy than creedmoor, but at the cost of requiring a long action, more recoil and if you handload, more burnt powder. With store bought ammo the price for a box of 20 rounds is likely the same. The negatives outweigh the positvies for me. And with a decent scope with some sort of bdc reticle, the flat trajectory advantage of the 270 is made a moot point. I handload, I shoot a decent amount of rounds per year, I prefer more efficient cartridges. Also, from the looking I’ve done (this applies to hand loading agian) the 6.5 has more variety when it comes to types of bullets. All the way from varmint bullets, light pointy bullets, heavy pointy bullets, mono bullets and (here’s where it looses 270) real heavy (for caliber) round nose bullets. 6.5, as a bore size, is pretty flexible. 6.5x55, 260 rem, 6.5-06, 6.5x284, 264 win mag, 6.5prc, 26 nosler, all good cartridges. Most fit different rolls, I choose the ones that work for me.

Good luck, hope you find a rifle you are really happy with!
 
Personally I would take an X bolt over a Tikka, but I would take a model 70 over either, another soon to be discontinued rifle that I like is the Sako A7, I think they are the equal of the X Bolt, I have one in 270 although if I was to buy again I would buy a 7 08. I usually compromise on the wood and synthetic and buy an aftermarket Boyd's laminate stock. In my opinion none of the rifles you mentioned are a bad choice.
 
Great responses, thanks! One more I am considering is a 2013ish Model 70 Super Grade, NIB. 300 Win however...

Might be overkill, but I assume I can load it down a bit.
 
V33

You mentioned that you would have preferred the x bolt hunter if it had a 20” barrel. I’m going to tell you about my current (and likely long standing) favourite gun: x bolt micro composite chambered in 6.5 creedmoor. The 13” length of pull is not too short for me (5’ 10”), and it is quite nice when wearing heavy layers when hunting. It is short (39 ish inches), has a 20” barrel, it’s light, handles like lightning and puts bullets right where I want them to go. Recoil is not bad at all. Where I hunt I am often in very thick stuff, most deer shot at 30 yards or so. But there are also some cut blocks that provide huge openings. I practice to 500 yards and am confident to that distance. If the animal is farther than that, I’ll get closer. It is a great rifle and I love how compact it is. I am considering chopping it to 18.5” though, time will tell. No irons on this model (as with most modern bolt actions), but as I said before, if you’re really worried about needing a backup sight system, something like a vortex venom thrown in the hunting pack would work fine.

One more gripe on x bolts (nothing is perfect!), the front sling swivel stud could be further forward, towards the front end of the stock. If it were mounted further forward the barrel would carry lower when carrying the gun with a sling over the shoulder. For a guy who walks through tangled willow patches, that would be appreciated. That is actually the reason I’m contemplating shortening the barrel, haha. I might just move the sling swivel stud forward though? Again, time will tell.

That Winchester 70 would be a beauty as well! I don’t think I could sleep at night if I thought about taking it where I hunt! I grew up shooting my dads model 70’s, really nice guns. I’m just not a fan of 90 degree bolts anymore. I like to get my scope as low as possible, just about laying on the barrel. I find that more difficult with most 90 degree bolt actions. Also, as mentioned before, I prefer the tang safety, it just feels right. The model 70 would be an heirloom rifle for sure, I don’t think I’d say the same for a synthetic stocked rifle with a composite magazine....
 
Last edited:
*UPDATE*

Found a rifle. Went with a Tikka T3X Battue with wood stock in .308

Optics-wise I think I am going to get a set of Talley rings and a Leupold VX-Freedom 2-7x33, unless any Tikka experts have another suggestion....?
 
Good choice in rifle.

I’m orobably too late to the party but since you got a battue with the very good integrated iron sights I’d suggest a set of warne QD rings, they clamp directly to the integrated rail of the receiver and will allow you to mount and dismount your scope quickly when desired.

Otherwise the Talley rings are great for a fixed scope mounting choice.
 
*UPDATE*

Found a rifle. Went with a Tikka T3X Battue with wood stock in .308

Optics-wise I think I am going to get a set of Talley rings and a Leupold VX-Freedom 2-7x33, unless any Tikka experts have another suggestion....?

Very nice choice. I always wanted one of those in 308/walnut but have too many other rifles to justify buying one.

Most of those Battues are found in synthetic. The walnut ones are much nicer. That rifle/scope set-up will handle nicely & serve you well.
 
Well done on the Tikka. The T3X is a sweet platform. Nice and accurate right out of the box.

For an optic, think about any lower-end Vortex scope like the Crossfire II. Nothing wrong with going 5-20X50 or 6-18X48. Never know when you might get the urge to start punching paper way, way out there....

Mr. Ted
 
Everywhere that allows rifle hunting, yes, but still places in Ontario that only allow shotgun for deer.

WMU's in Ontario that have "shotguns only-no dogs" deer season are also the ones where there's a .270 or smaller rule for SMALL game. Black Bear (BIG game) hunters hunting where there's an open Black Bear season may still use larger caliber rifles in those areas except during the shotgun season for deer. There,clear as mud? :cheers:
 
Nothing can do it all the best but. But something that can 8 out of 10 in most situations is what you won't. Several good ones out there. But mine is 300wsm, stainless, 19inch barrel, under 8lb scoped and loaded, 38 inches overall length. 165 at 3000fps zero at 300yds 10.5 low at 400yds. Thick stuff to long mountain shots, dogs to moose.
 
Curious if anyone in this thread knows for sure but since the 6.5 Creed is technically .264 calibre does it also work within the calibre restrictions in southern Ontario? Or is there some technicality that this gets tripped up on within the regulations?

Edit - looks like good to go on this....googling is a wonderful thing
 
Last edited:
In answer to your TITLE my answer will always be the Browning BLR. If for all Ont. game then .308 or bigger.
My exsperience with mine is over 40 yrs of hunting & kills. It has everything you need ; safe , good weight,
good size, fast repeating , scopable , accurate , clip & more.
 
My do-it-all caliber would have to be a .270win shooting 140 accubonds. I’ve taken many moose with one, they fall the same as if hit with my .300rum.
It’s also imo one of the best suited deer rounds you can get, 200 yard zero and it’s pretty much point and shoot to 400 yards give or take.
If I could have only one . It would be my .270 tikka.
 
CZ or Tikka T3X Battue would be my pick for quality and iron sights in 270. Other calibres I would look at include the usual crop of 6.5's and the quarter bores like 25-06. I've recently developed a fondness for 260 Rem. There's a new in box T3 Sporter in 260 on EE... no irons though. Irons are a deal breaker for me as well.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom