The Benchmark gave (on average) groups about .25" better from my rifle using Hornady 55 gr V-max bullets(5-shot groups, Savage VLP) than the H-335. Velocity was about 75 fps more as well. I have 6 or 7 pounds of H-335 and 700 Speer 52 gr. bullets right now, so I'm using them up. I never paid too much attention as to whether it was a whole lot cleaner, and the cost really isn't a factor to me.
Some of the combinations that have worked for me are:
Hodgdon BL(C)-2 with 55 gr. Sierra PSP bullets - avg group .75" 3313 fps
Hodgdon Varget with Nosler 55 gr Ballistic Tips - avg group .86" @ 3220 fps
Hodgdon Benchmark with 55 gr V-max - avg group .5" @ 3225 fps
Hodgdon H-335 with Speer 52 gr HP - avg group .75" @ 3160 fps.
I just realized right now that Hodgdon powder works well for me!
I've tried lots of other powders, but I have lots of the Hodgdon stuff in the locker.
Now if I could find a powder that will work well with Winchester 55 gr. PSP bullets, I'll be happy (I have 1500 of them and nothing I've tried has given less than 2" groups).
Thanks for all the details. I tried Winchester super X ammo in my sako .243 a little while ago with pretty crappy results. Talking to my brother it sounds like most peoples experience, so I'm a little sour on winchester. In the older super X ammo I shot I had four brass split completely down the neck which freaked me out. The federal v shok shot MuCH better.