The only real issues I've noticed with mirror polished firearms is that the blue wears faster than it does on matte or just luster polished.
I have never noticed any issues with splotchy coverage, as long as everything is absolutely free of oils. I saw a lovely hot blue job, done by a very good smith, that really knew his stuff. He had hired some help to run a couple of batches through his bluing tanks. The fellow was very ambitious and worked fast.
Lo and behold, several of the bbls had "Splotchy Finishes". Not only that, they had a purplish hue. Upon inspection, the new fellow had oil on his hands. He thought that if he kept his hands oily, he wouldn't rust the finish on the rifles.
He was one of those people plagued with "super sweat". You've all met them, you have to wipe down your firearms after they handle them.