I'am glad I came across this info tonight. I recently purchased a Mueller tactical scope for my Win Mod 70 in .300 WSM and took off an el-cheapo Busnell wide angle 4X12X40 scope (made in Korea) to replace it. I looked at all the fancy Busnell tactical ones (I like the idea of the mil-dot) and a bunch of the others, but my Gunsmith said I can't go wrong with this Mueller scope for what I wanted (all I wanted to do was to be able to hit a bull elk at 300 yards) He said he would order it in, and if I don't like it, or don't want it, he would buy it back for the same price, can't go wrong with that.
So, today my buddy and I head out to the range to try this thing out. I have been around guns for a long time, and thought I knew something about scopes and could simply take off the Bushnell and replace it with my new Meuller in the Weaver mounts I had proffesionally installed sometime ago and bore site the Mod 70. I shot one shot at a huge .95 cent target at 50 yard and I wasn't even on the paper, jesus, now what?, scope must be NFG? We both stood there scratching our heads then along came this Steve guy whom after we introduced ourselves began telling us all about installing a new scope (he could tell we didn't have a clue). Steve had a little kit bag full of scope mounting levels and adjustable torque gunsmith screwdrivers and tons of advice on mounting scopes and went to work for us.
To make a long story short, Steve got the scope all torqued up and shooting on the paper in no time, but made a few comments that relate and verify the above threads. First he said that Weaver mounts are the worst and hardest to instal a scope in if you are not familiar with them. Second, he never Locktites his mounting screws (which is a debatable subject in itself), but relies on proper torque values, rather than Locktite.
The most interesting thing that Steve said was that all the bull elk he has shot (Steve has apparantly shot 13), they were all at about 100 yards away and the closest was 11 yards and the farthest was 220 yards. Hmmm, why did I buy this $900 Winchester and put a $460 scope on it and spend $100 worth of ammo sighting it in when I could of just used my trusty old Remington 7600 pump in .308 (Really old Bushnell 4 power scope)
To sum this up, I think I should let you know what at least I learned from all this for what it's worth
#1 leave the scope mounting to a proffesional if you are not sure
#2 never Locktite your scope mounts because torque should do it and you may want to change the eye relief or vertical alignment of your crosshairs later (Steve did say he may consider the purple Locktite)
#3 Don't ever think you need a 7 zillion dollar scope for you rifle when there are many others available that will do a surprisingly good job for way less (we are not A USMC sniper, and I am very happy with the new Meuller scope I bought for what I want to shoot at)
#4, now that I think of it, why can't we just go into the old gun cabinet and take out hunting and USE one of our old trusty favorite 30-30's, or .303 Enfield sportorized (instead of buying that $1000 plus rifle and scope that our wives don't want us to have anyway?), or what have you and still be able to shoot good enough to put meat in the freezer?
#5 Steve says you don't need (and actually laughed at us about this) a .95 cent target, he uses 1/4 inch grauf (sp?)paper and a black magic marker spot in the middle.
Have a safe and bountiful hunting season guys, and remember if the women can't find you hansome, they always love a hunter who comes home with the meat.