How we field butcher big critters: not quartering, not gutless - but in-between

Longwalker

CGN Ultra frequent flyer
GunNutz
Rating - 100%
213   0   2
Location
Saskatchewan
When a big animal like an elk or moose is successfully hunted, it seems like they often drop in the most inconvenient place possible. So you need a plan. I gave up long ago trying to get most whole animals out of the bush, they're just too big and heavy and hard to handle. Some hunters advocate the "gutless" method, whereby meat is stripped form the bone and all pieces bagged for transport. That makes the smallest packages, great for backpackers who need to pack out meat as light as possible but it is easy to contaminate lots of prime cuts with dirt, air exposure, and general mishaps. It is also illegal in places like BC where proof of ### must stay with the carcass. I believe meat should be hung in a cooler for a week or so to age properly, and if you do that, hanging on the bone is the best because the meat does not shorten in rigor mortis.

My family's usual method is quite different than hanging and "quartering" an animal, which I believe is a relic of the commercial domestic meat industry. Some butchers require carcasses delivered to them as if they are beef from an abattoir, and make all their cuts on a bandsaw the same as beef. If you use such a butcher, this advice is not for you. You are stuck with that type of service, and the corresponding compromise to meat quality. I'd like to suggest a better way. I come from several generations of commercial butchers, and handling meat is "in my blood" so to speak. But I do not cut game meat with a saw. I think that bone "sawdust" is very bad for meat quality. A saw is really only needed for a couple of cuts in the field. We cut all our meat using knives only. Separate into muscle groups, remove fat and contamination, then cut steaks and roasts cross grain. If a whole animal can be easily retrieved, we may not separate the carcass in the field. But for all those more typical packing jobs, this is how we do it...

The plan starts with the right equipment. Bring a half dozen good quality cotton meat bags. I prefer home made, close woven cotton over "cheesecloth" but some commercial mesh bags are OK if they are not too open weave. A folding bone saw like a Gerber exchange-a-blade saw is great for sternum, and ribs. Coarse wood saw teeth like those on the commonly available Coghlan's Sierra folding saw are too coarse for best service when cutting bone. A hatchet can work, but is heavy, leaves sharp bone shards, and is not as safe to use with bloody or cold hands. A hunting knife that has a 6" or so long fairly straight blade is better for separating the hind legs and shoulders than a shorter one, but a 4" drop point, curved blade is better for gutting and skinning. It's a picky detail but I sometimes take two knives, carry the shorter one for gutting and skinning, pack along the longer one for separating the carcass. It doesn't add much weight, and the longer straighter deboning knife stays tucked away in the pack frame anyway. Put a bundle of paracord in the pack frame too. It is handy for many things during butchering, especially hanging bagged meat in the cooling breeze until you can come for it later. And a plastic bag for liver and heart if you want to keep them.

We always tag & field dress ASAP where the animal has fallen. Especially important in early season hunts that may be 20°C. Then go for the pack frame and meat bags and buddies to help.

Cut off head, and cut legs off at the joints. Skin the top side, laying skin out flat to keep a clean surface to roll the carcass over on later. So don't step on it! Remove the top side shoulder & bag it. Remove hind leg and bag it. Most do this by finding the ball joint near the pelvis, cutting it loose with tip of your knife and and then carefully following the pelvis arch and backbone around to keep all the good sirloin steaks with the cut. An even better way that leaves less meat exposed is to remove the tenderloins and bag them, then cut through the pelvic arch with a saw, then find the sacro-iliac joint in the pelvic girdle. It's at a slight angle to the backbone and on either side of it. A properly applied knife tip will "Like magic" separate the two sides of the bony pelvis from the backbone and tail area.


Using the saw, cut off the topside rib slab close to the backbone without hitting the meaty rib steaks area. Bag it.

Flip the carcass over on the clean hide and repeat. If you followed those directions, you will be left with the long loin from which you can separate the bit of backbone and tail that is waste, and the rib&neck section. I usually spit the spine into two parts, cut crossways between the second and third ribs. the front part is the heaviest singe piece, especially on a moose because of that big neck. But it should be manageable for one person and a pack frame.

Now the real hard work begins, but all that good and well cared for meat is worth it!
 

Attachments

  • IMG_1322.jpg
    IMG_1322.jpg
    47.3 KB · Views: 686
  • IMG_1323.jpg
    IMG_1323.jpg
    46.3 KB · Views: 684
  • IMG_1324.jpg
    IMG_1324.jpg
    46.5 KB · Views: 683
  • IMG_0568.jpg
    IMG_0568.jpg
    50.1 KB · Views: 686
  • IMG_0522.jpg
    IMG_0522.jpg
    50 KB · Views: 686
  • IMG_0526.jpg
    IMG_0526.jpg
    50.1 KB · Views: 691
  • IMG_E0529.jpg
    IMG_E0529.jpg
    50.2 KB · Views: 684
Thanks for posting your detailed meat breakdown longwalker. You certainly seem to have your procedure down to a great system. We still usually quarter our big animals and did that to the elk we got last fall and used a plastic sled to do the long haul back to the truck.
 
Thanks for posting Longwalker. Question for you...

We always cut the rib ends to the left or right of the sternum. You do the same? Pretty easy to use a brisket buster on a SwissArmy knife to go through that rather than cutting the sternum in half. What do you think?
 
I cut the ends of the ribs on young animals, calves and yearlings. You can do that with a knife. Either side, or both sides of the sternum. It's easy and exactly where you cut doesn't really matter. Just follow the cartilage ends of the rib joints. I use a saw up the middle for the older more "ossified" bulls. I like eating ribs, bone in, otherwise it would be just as efficient to debone the ribs in the field and leave the bones behind.
Please explain what a "brisket buster" on a Swiss Army Knife is. Haven't seen that in action yet. I'd like to learn. When hunting roe deer and wild boar in Germany they cut the sternum, pelvis and sometimes legs with a big pruning shears. I thought that was kinda cool, but not practical to pack along where we hunt.
 
Here's an old account of gutless butchering for deer.20210222_154132.jpg
 

Attachments

  • 20210222_154132.jpg
    20210222_154132.jpg
    90.8 KB · Views: 544
I cut the ends of the ribs on young animals, calves and yearlings. You can do that with a knife. Either side, or both sides of the sternum. It's easy and exactly where you cut doesn't really matter. Just follow the cartilage ends of the rib joints. I use a saw up the middle for the older more "ossified" bulls. I like eating ribs, bone in, otherwise it would be just as efficient to debone the ribs in the field and leave the bones behind.
Please explain what a "brisket buster" on a Swiss Army Knife is. Haven't seen that in action yet. I'd like to learn. When hunting roe deer and wild boar in Germany they cut the sternum, pelvis and sometimes legs with a big pruning shears. I thought that was kinda cool, but not practical to pack along where we hunt.

Brisket buster is hard to find. I'll get my mentor to post it up in due course.
 
We do pretty much the same on moose and snow less caribou hunt, when there is snow on the ground for caribou we usually gut them and slide them to the truck on a tarp!
 
Nice write up, I do the same on deer once home. Clean skinning and handling of the meat is an important factor to ensure your meat will be as tasty as possible. I use a small utility hand saw that takes sawzall or hacksaw blades to cut the pelvis and breastbone in the field, super lightweight and easy to clean.
 
Please explain what a "brisket buster" on a Swiss Army Knife is. Haven't seen that in action yet. I'd like to learn. When hunting roe deer and wild boar in Germany they cut the sternum, pelvis and sometimes legs with a big pruning shears. I thought that was kinda cool, but not practical to pack along where we hunt.

I am guessing he is referring to the saw blade on some models.

A friend of mine quartered a moose with one, so they could load it out. He had time on his hands...
I usually carry a folding pruning saw in my gear bag.
 
Just a note that gutless is 100% legal in BC. Just leave the evidence of ### attached to one hind leg and a strip of hide attached to each quarter. Gutless you don't necessarily bone out the legs either. Depends how far you have to pack it.

You have a similar method to the way we do it. Although we rarely go into the gut cavity until all the meat is off and we want to get to the tenderloin, heart and liver. I agree that bringing out animals whole or in quarters is often more trouble than it's worth and it certainly doesn't facilitate the cooling process.
 
Last edited:
Good post Longwalker - Thanks

As I mentioned on another post I have always preferred butchers who don't cut into the bone - 100% agree it changes the taste of the meat.
 
Great post, Longwalker. My son and I generally proceed the same as you. After field photograph's, we immediately start skinning. A knife each, Wyoming Saw and cheesecloth is all what is required. With two of us, it only takes about 15 to 20 minutes to have a deer skinned, gutted and in the back of the truck in cheesecloth.

With elk and moose, well that's a different story, we never take a whole animal out. We start skinning right away (after field photograph's). Two knives each, Wyoming Saw, 12 cheesecloth bags, and large black plastic bags for scraps. All 4 quarters and other large cuts are placed in cheesecloth, neck and rib meat as well. Usually 3 to 3.5 hours and all is done with these big animals.
https://imgur.com/a/uH5MIa9
 
12(?!?!?) game bags?? That seems a bit excessive for one moose or elk.

These are bags to fit the quarters in, not the general long cheesecloth bags for deer. Besides, we are allowed a bull elk each; therefore a few extra is great to have. We've also gave many cheese cloth bags to other hunters (never knew them),who failed to have any. I hate to see good meat covered in dirt, dust or hair on the way home.;)
 
These are bags to fit the quarters in, not the general long cheesecloth bags for deer. Besides, we are allowed a bull elk each; therefore a few extra is great to have. We've also gave many cheese cloth bags to other hunters (never knew them),who failed to have any. I hate to see good meat covered in dirt, dust or hair on the way home.;)

The way I read that the first time it sounded like you use 12 bags PER elk.


I don't disagree with you on seeing quarters with hair or dirt. Personal pet peeve.
 
Back
Top Bottom