Hunter shot by another Hunter near Calgary

96Brigadier

Regular
EE Expired
Rating - 100%
10   0   0
Location
Calgary
From the Sunday, November 13th Calgary Herald

‘Here I am, my buddy is bleeding to death’
Frantic call for help followed hunting mishap

RENATA D’ALIESIO CALGARY HERALD

Brian Reardigan’s voice was hoarse Saturday. He strained it yelling desperately in the wilderness after crashing his truck into a tree with his friend beside him, bleeding from a gunshot wound.

“Here I am, my buddy is bleeding to death,” Reardigan said of the events that unfolded Friday as they were bow-hunting. “I get out of the truck and just started screaming for help.”

Help came from the hunter who shot his friend.

Reardigan, 35, and his 42-year-old buddy were setting up a deer decoy when his friend was shot in the side of the abdomen. The victim, who has not been named, was taken to Foothills hospital Friday in critical, but stable condition.

Reardigan conceded Saturday the foolishness of their hunt.
“We did something very stupid,” he said. “As safe as we thought it was, it wasn’t.”

But, he said, their foolishness is just part of the story.

The Calgary residents were in a wooded area in the Waiparous, 23 kilometres north of Highway 1A, west of Secondary Highway 940, also know as the Forestry Trunk Road.

The area is popular with hunters. Autumn is especially good for hunting mule and white-tail deer because it’s rutting time, when males are constantly in search of a mate.

Dressed in camouflage, Reardigan said the pair had driven around for a bit in the afternoon to find a good spot for the decoy.

His friend had the decoy in hand, about 32 metres from the pickup truck, when gunshots ripped apart the early afternoon’s silence.

Reardigan was bent down in his pickup, gathering rebar and an axe to steady the decoy deer, when he heard the blasts.
“All I could hear was him screaming, ‘I’ve been shot. I’ve been shot. I’ve been shot.’ ”

He ran to his friend, and at first didn’t see any blood. When his friend turned, blood began to pour from his side.

The shooter, who identified himself as Stan, then arrived. “I’m so sorry. I’m so sorry,” Reardigan recalled him saying.

Reardigan said he didn’t have binoculars or a telescope on his rifle. Reardigan has been bow-hunting for five years. He said his friend took up the activity just this year. Stuart Sinclair-Smith, an archeryhunting outfitter in Calgary, said it’s extremely dangerous for bow hunters with a decoy to wade into an area with rifle hunters. “You never go out with a decoy in a rifle zone. That’s just foolhardy,” he said. “It’s not good common sense.”

Rifle-hunting season opened in the area Sept. 17, said Donna Babchishin, a spokeswoman for Alberta Sustainable Resource Development.

Reardigan tried to call for help on his cellphone, but couldn’t get reception. He ran back for his pickup and scooped up his wounded friend.

But as Reardigan raced out of the woods, he lost control, veered off the road and slammed into a tree.

Panic set in.

Reardigan began screaming for help and waving his arms, hoping to flag down a passing vehicle. He says that’s when Stan, the 55-year-old shooter from Airdrie, Cochrane’s Ivan Jacek and another man came by in a pickup.

Reardigan said he loaded his friend into their truck. He disputed details relayed by Jacek to reporters Friday.

He said Jacek was hunting with Stan and didn’t just meet him by the road.

Jacek couldn’t be reached for comment Saturday. On Friday, he said Stan was panicked, saying he didn’t see the hunter. He said Stan kept repeating, “I’m so stupid, I’m so stupid.” Reardigan planned to visit his friend again Saturday night. Cochrane RCMP are investigating the shooting. The hunter’s name has not been released. Reardigan said his friend underwent surgery Friday.
 
We were in that area all weekend. Didn't even know about this until last night. We were literally less then 5kms away! :shock:
 
This is why I like to be as remote as possible when I go hunting. What a tragic accident for all those involved.
 
AceShooter said:
If it was in a rifle zone why were they wearing camo instead of orange? Or was it a muzzleloader?

Who cares?!? I "rifle-hunt" in camo all the time. Of course, I also know what a real, live deer looks like.

The idiot that shot him should be hung.
 
Good decoys are very realistic and nobody can tell the difference under all conditions. Using decoys should be done with extreme caution and hunter orange... this tragedy could have been avoided using common sense. I hope the hunter makes a full recovery.
 
What a tragedy. A fully camo'd bow hunter with a decoy in a bow/rifle zone and a rifle hunter who never fully ID'd his target. This recipe for disaster was completely avoidable and puts another "feather in the cap" of anti-hunters everywhere...(this is the most civilized way I could put it)...KF
 
Trigger happy

I'm with agilent one! A person shouldn't have to wear orange or red to protect themselves. People should not be so trigger happy and FULLY know what they are firing at and what is behind it PERIOD. Giving excuses for these kinds of incidents will only lead to more "accidents" happening!! TOTALLY unacceptable!
 
Jeeasuuz,

What a story. Big Redds right though, the decoys today look really lifelike.

I think common sense was one factor but plain ####ty luck turned the scales on this one. Poor bastards.
 
This is why I shy away from using decoys in a big game season. Even if orange was a requirement in Alberta (it's not) at some point you have to get close to the decoy and you could be in a blind spot and still end up shot. Gould you imagine your behind the decoy jiggling it to put it up or down, some othe guy sees it but not you the decoy is moving and boomm your dead.

I think if I used decoys it would be only on private land and if I could tip it over remotly (string ?) and I would have an orange sack to carry it in.
 
The following letter was printed in the Calgary Sun this morning:

http://calsun.canoe.ca/Comment/Letters/2005/11/16/1308716.html

"RE: "Hunting mishap a fluke," (Nov. 13.) They call it a sport -- hiding in the bush with a high-powered rifle or a bow killing an animal from a distance. I've always felt hunters to be of low intelligence. Turns out to be true and all I can do is laugh. No pity from me.

Alan Perkins

(Bizarre sense of humour.)"


I don't understand some people. Why would anyone "laugh" at a tragedy like this??
 
I have heard of guys putting a big orange vest on their decoys while heading out in the field which may prevent a guy from shooting but you never know and accidents do happen.
 
Scott_N said:
The following letter was printed in the Calgary Sun this morning:

http://calsun.canoe.ca/Comment/Letters/2005/11/16/1308716.html

"RE: "Hunting mishap a fluke," (Nov. 13.) They call it a sport -- hiding in the bush with a high-powered rifle or a bow killing an animal from a distance. I've always felt hunters to be of low intelligence. Turns out to be true and all I can do is laugh. No pity from me.

Alan Perkins

(Bizarre sense of humour.)"


I don't understand some people. Why would anyone "laugh" at a tragedy like this??

because he is an ass. no more, no less.
 
Tragic story no doubt...but how much less common sense can one, or still worse, a group of hunters have???

I am torn between...

1) Feeling empathy for both the shooter and the hunter that was shot.

...and...

2) Feeling that they all got what the deserved for being so irresponsible.

The scary thing is that point #2) above is winning out in my mind!!!

Anybody setting up a decoy in rifle season, and in a rifle area, in full camo deserves to be shot. I mean come on, you might as well be a bullet magnet!!!

And anybody that takes a shot without being 110% certain of their target doesn't deserve to be pulling the trigger...EVER.

All 3 are a danger to hunting and every hunter out there.

I too rifle hunt in full camo. I wear NO blaze orange. I realize that is perhaps risky but I also trust that fellow hunters in the field verify their target before easing the safety off and pulling the trigger. Perhaps I should not be so optimistic!!! Regardless, I wouldn't be caught dead setting up a decoy without being highly visible as human!!!

I hope the guy that got shot is alright and has a full recovery.
 
It5's very easy to condemm someone as incompetant for something like this, but none of us here know all the aspects of the incident.

The fella in camo may have been in a shadow, and as was stated, many decoys are very lifelike.
However, I would not be anywhere near one without weqaring blaze ornage!
But , I always carry binoculars as well, seeing's how my eyesight is going downhill.

I remember a story a few years back when a deeer was seen running around with an arrow in its neck, and many figured the guy responsible should have been shot , had his hunting rights tasken away, etc.

However, andy of us could have made the same shot if the arrow had clipped a branch, or some other unfortunate thing had caused a perfectly good shot to go bad.

I feel badly for all invovled here, and hope evrything turns out as well as can be expected
Cat
 
We do use decoys... I had one set up about 150 yards from the road... right in front of a wack shack with the windows open. I actually had people get out of the vehicle walk past no tresspassing signs to get closer.
I figured I was safe in the wack shack wearing an orange hat and vest with the hat was clearly visible through the huge open windows. The damn wack shack is only 30 yards from the decoy and out in the open in a food plot.
I will never use a decoy during the gun hunt again... I can tell you this for free... people are stupid... and buck fever can effect peoples judgement and perception.
You had better be as cautious and smart as you can... for yourself and the other hunters as well.
 
catnthehatt said:
It5's very easy to condemm someone as incompetant for something like this, but none of us here know all the aspects of the incident.

The fella in camo may have been in a shadow, and as was stated, many decoys are very lifelike.
However, I would not be anywhere near one without weqaring blaze ornage!
But , I always carry binoculars as well, seeing's how my eyesight is going downhill.

I remember a story a few years back when a deeer was seen running around with an arrow in its neck, and many figured the guy responsible should have been shot , had his hunting rights tasken away, etc.

However, andy of us could have made the same shot if the arrow had clipped a branch, or some other unfortunate thing had caused a perfectly good shot to go bad.

I feel badly for all invovled here, and hope evrything turns out as well as can be expected
Cat


Wounding a deer - or other big game animal - with an arrow (regardless of the circumstances that caused it to happen) or even a rifle for that matter, is an entirely different can of worms than setting up a decoy in rifle season, in a rifle area, in full camo!!!

I agree, none of us were there to really witness all the events leading up to the accident but based on what has been reported...this is a fantastic case of 3 people completely lacking any degree of common sense!!!
 
what's next? dress up like deer and walk on all fours to get a sparring rush with the buck of your dreams?
sorry for the mishap.

as for the letter writer... not all hunters are smart. Is a natural fact that applies to all groups of beings. It is explained in detail by the Gauss "bell" theory.
But as an average.... huntes are waaaay more inteligent than letter-writers.
 
Shooster, the point I ws trying to make was that sometimes there are circumstances that we as readers are not aware of.
However, if I was going to set up a decoy you can bet that I would be weraing a bunch of orange!
The guy may have been down below the shooters line of sight or something like that, but I still think it goes back to being completely certain of your target before firing.....
Cat
 
Back
Top Bottom