Im a rookie and I need help

Learning as I go. How did you know that the "very tight to chamber" was a length issue, and not a "fat case" issue? I don't think my SAAMI GO or NOGO gauges do the case walls or the case head diameter, just the headspace length - so what you describe can also be from cases "too fat" or not tapered enough. I am assuming that you did Jiffy Marker or soot trick to find out the issue?? SAAMI calls out min and max diameters as well as min and max headspace, so more than one way to be "minimum spec", but two different issues??

You can find out whether it is a "length" issue vs a "diameter" issue by lighting a wax candle, ans smoking the whole case.
Then try to chamber it. If the smoked section that shows evidence of contact is only the shoulder, you have a length issue. If
the case has the carbon removed from the outside of the case, particularly near the base, you have a diameter issue.

As I mentioned in my previous post, [re: my custom 308 Norma Mag] Both issues could be present. Dave.
 
While I really respect your and others opinions here I still lean towards just taking it to a gunsmith. While many of you are well spoken, and in my opinion, unsanctioned professionals in the field of firearms people need to work in there skill set. Plus it’s often faster and cheaper to get a pro. Heck, I can tell you how easy it is to rebuilt the starter on your truck, fix your dryer or replace your smartphone screen but none of those will blow up in your face. I would rather take a gun to a smith who would tell me the problem (if it was actually a problem rather than an issue) how it could be fixed or dealt with. I am going to learn as well as save money. The last time I bought go no go gauges I think a set was like $125.

Have a great day all.

SCG

Probably a total de-rail of this thread, but hoping that you do know there is no standardized training, apprenticeship or certification for a "gunsmith" in Canada? Apparently, can almost buy a "licence" and announce to the world that you are a "gunsmith". But skill and know-how is developed, a reputation is developed, and "cream" rises to the top. From reading, a military armourer has a humungous supply network backing him up for a specific and finite number of arms, written standardized procedures to follow for each make and model he is authorized to "fix", and keeps that stuff working to spec. A "gunsmith" may or may not even have a purchasing assistant, let alone a supply chain, for every possible make, model and age of arm that might come through his door. A gunsmith makes what he needs, if necessary. So, a gunsmith is a welder, a machinist, an old-time blacksmith, an excellent wood worker, and often a tool and die maker.

I apprenticed for 48 months, during which I attended 32 weeks at "Tech" and became a Journeyman Electrician - it happens that I have a Red Seal on my certificate. Despite looking for years, there is just no equivalent to that to become a "gunsmith". I spent my working days in Saskatchewan, and had to maintain a "Saskatchewan Electrical Licence", in order to work at that trade in that province, after attaining my Journeyman's. I believe there is a similar "licence" for a gunsmith but I do not know who issues that or if it is required in all provinces or not. So, the Post #19 has a lot of merit, but seems to rely an awful lot on a profession that has not been held to very high standards?? I do not mean to dis that trade at all - just the "odds" of running into a "wanna-be" seem fairly high, versus the guys that are really good and knowledgeable at what they do.
 
Last edited:
Yes, and your right, being a tradesman as well I have seen hacks in every aspect of everything regardless of training or certification. Maybe I should have clarified it with the words a known good or competent smith?

As with anything some people just don’t possess the skill set or possibly the understanding to do some tasks regardless of how well it’s described to them. Then with multiple ideas it could become confusing. While some may feel it things like this should be known to safely reload it probably isn’t.

I do appreciate all your guys knowledge and willingness to share.

SCG

Probably a total de-rail of this thread, but hoping that you do know there is no standardized training, apprenticeship or certification for a "gunsmith" in Canada? Apparently, can almost buy a "licence" and announce to the world that you are a "gunsmith". But skill and know-how is developed, a reputation is developed, and "cream" rises to the top. From reading, a military armourer has a humungous supply network backing him up for a specific and finite number of arms, written standardized procedures to follow for each make and model he is authorized to "fix", and keeps that stuff working to spec. A "gunsmith" may or may not even have a purchasing assistant, let alone a supply chain, for every possible make, model and age of arm that might come through his door. A gunsmith makes what he needs, if necessary. So, a gunsmith is a welder, a machinist, an old-time blacksmith, an excellent wood worker, and often a tool and die maker.

I apprenticed for 48 months, during which I attended 32 weeks at "Tech" and became a Journeyman Electrician - it happens that I have a Red Seal on my certificate. Despite looking for years, there is just no equivalent to that to become a "gunsmith". I spent my working days in Saskatchewan, and had to maintain a "Saskatchewan Electrical Licence", in order to work at that trade in that province, after attaining my Journeyman's. I believe there is a similar "licence" for a gunsmith but I do not know who issues that or if it is required in all provinces or not. So, the Post #19 has a lot of merit, but seems to rely an awful lot on a profession that has not been held to very high standards?? I do not mean to dis that trade at all - just the "odds" of running into a "wanna-be" seem fairly high, versus the guys that are really good and knowledgeable at what they do.
 
Okay... where did the OP disappear to?

A bunch jumped in to help... and poof! There he was - gone!
 
Back
Top Bottom