Is he a shooter or would you pass?

[Dimitri]

I'd have shot it faster then the camara guy would have been able to take a picture of it.

Dimitri

 

[bootz]

I wasnt asking for advice, I was asking would "YOU" shoot or would you pass.

The question was hypothetical...

I assumed you started the thread asking for opinions, sorry, so to answer your specific question:

my answer is no.

 

[Cletus]

I wouldnt hesitate on that. Cuz I would have an extra tag to fill it with a bigger one if the opportunity came up. Heck I wouldnt even complain if you shot it and put my tag on it. They all taste the same!

 

[Levi Garrett]

Heck I wouldnt even complain if you shot it and put my tag on it

 

[death-junky]

hells yes!
ttyal
Riley

 

[rdelliott]

So is this deer a shooter or would you pass him up and wait till the rut is on to maybe try and find a bigger one (and yes, they are there). A friend took these pics last week.

I know what I would do

Me too.

Blam.

 

[WCTHEMI]

The pic would have my rifle perched in his rack, and me with a grin on my face. Might not be "world class", but worth the tag in my eyes.

 

[harv3589]

I would pass, knowing that the chance for a bigger one is there...I love to hunt and if I shot him its over.

 

[crazy_davey]

I love to hunt and if I shot him its over.

Thats the worst part of the whole thing

But if ya plan your season right a person can still have lots of tags to fill

 

[Steeleco]

Bang flop, done deal. Go for bigger next year!!

 

[powder burner]

seeing as how I have only one weekend this year, he's down.

 

[Elk man]

He's a shooter...no questions asked.

 

[bigben]

oh my down in a heart beat !!!!!!!!!!

 

[Timberlord]

I'd put a slug into that buck quicker than a hic-up

 

[cereal83]

I would shoot. I have seen bigger in my old town but I would still shot as I am a noob

 

[rainman]

thats a nice buck,if you pass him up you probably wont see another one as big,been there

 

[Noel]

I'd love to see some with junk on it, I seem to only ever catch real clean 4x's out in the open. Saw one last night that's going to give me nightmares until I'm drawn again

Hi Tmac, sounds like a trade in the works!
I was told there was a clean 4 point in the area where I ended up taking this one. He was supossedly 210 net! Never saw him, just his monster tracks.
I passed on this one opening day, and then on my second last day to hunt had another opportunity, the rest is history. It would be nice to get one like that picture from Corlanes! In my dreams!

This kind of genetics seems quite common in 314, for the ones I find anyway, this one has over 11 inches in deductions I think.

 

[9mikemike]

HHMM I hunt for the meat, 1/2 a second he's on the ground.

 

[Maple Leaf Pilgrim]

BANG

 

[Silverado]

That deer would be coming home in the back of my truck.