Lol well said. I'm just after a .22lr to take rabbits etc and get my boy into hunting as gets older (he turns 3 this month). Something that works fine out of the box with minimal changes and customization is ideal in this case.
I will take a look at the Marlins and Savage! Thanks for your help!
Honestly, if you ask 100 people if the 10/22 is any good, you are going to find around 50 that love it, another 30 that like it, and 20 that hate it. Don't flame me here, I don't have any data, just a guess. Pretty much the same with any semi auto. This is because everyone gets to try a relatively small sample size and then they start to generalize about all the remaining guns out there. I'm in the 30 group above btw.
You can see it in this thread, the first replys were positive, then the 10/22 haters showed up.
Ask me how i feel about the savage 64, I'll say I hate em. Ditto the Nylon 66. And I have reasons. But I can assure you some say they are among the best.
Marlin semis are a solid meh for me, mainly due to the trigger. Don't hate em, don't love em.
Some guys think hitting a tin can at 50 yards is hunting accuracy, some will want to head shoot squirrels at 50 yards and so even there, there are many different standards.
Now if a guy tries a few kinds of ammo in a given gun and finds it isn't accurate with them he generally concludes the gun is inaccurate. But the same gun that shoots 1.5-2" groups at 50 yards may shoot another variety into 1/2". It takes a lot of effort to determine these things, and I suspect many guys never do that testing.
From what I've read, the 10/22 is on average just as accurate as the other semi 22's that are available.
Ok, so in my opinion, the 10/22 is a great squirrel/rabbit gun. It is light, accurate enough, shoots well, is generally very reliable and you can always add stuff to make it shoot even better. They are not perfect but most folks are very happy with them, in my experience. I personally prefer the ones with the aluminum trigger housing over the later plastic ones, but apparently they shoot about the same. Put it another way, the 10/22 is my favorite gopher gun ever (and many love it for that purpose). And if you can use one for gophers, it will do just as well for rabbit and squirrels.
Since you want to introduce your son to it someday, it will be a good choice for that, as they are generally light, short and point well. However, a semi auto is not really the best gun for a young boy to start with, and you will do well to start him on a little single shot or something and leave the semi automatic for a later time.
Ok, so having said that, if I were in your shoes, the first semi I would look for is an old brno 581. They are an exceptional rifle in a field of many good choice.
Here's a link to one on the EE right now:
https://www.canadiangunnutz.com/forum/showthread.php/2130316-REDUCED-Brno-581-Winchester-Wildcat-2-semi-autos?highlight=brno
these guns are never cheap, but are known for their accuracy and brilliant design. For me that's never worked out. The 10/22 is doing everything just fine.
One more thing, those that hunt squirrels in particular love shooting the 17HM2 over the 22 long rifle, because it is generally accurate enough for headshots, has far less drop than a 22 LR so more range and less hold over requirements, and puts them down better than a 22 LR, but without blowing them up ala 17HMR. I suspect it would offer the same advantages over the 22 LR on rabbits as well.
However, this is generally a bolt action only chambering. Just sayin.
Good luck