Ithaca Model 37

I was always on the look out for a used but not abused Ithaca 37 in 3" but no luck. How come all the versions available are in full choked?

Likely going to need to try and find either an Ithaca 87 or the newer 37's to get a 3" chamber. Like Maritime Storm said Full choke is by far the most common, it was a very versatile choke when lead was the only shot to be encountered. Spreader loads could be made for upland if needed, waterfowl and turkey it would serve equally well for and even buckshot and rifled slugs would get the job done when called upon. Unfortunately we had nontoxic shots forced upon us (many are harder than lead) and unfortunately in some cases bad things happen when its fired through an older fixed full choke.
 
I have 2. Both featherweight. Both 12 ga. One has been cut to 26" cyl an the other is a factory mod 28" that was my first shotgun. The stock was cut and now it's to short. I'd love a straight stock and a fellow cgn member says he can make me one. I'm in search of a blank but have to many projects on the go. When our dollar comes back ill buy a new 28 ga field with exhibition wood. Love the 37
 
I kind of want to find a 20gauge one with chokes now, shame there is no dealer in Canada. I could have bought a 20 guage off a dealer that was selling out a while ago, but didn't want to spend the money on a gun I hadn't even seen before (maybe I am part of the problem then). I have taken my 12 guage out trap shooting several times now and am averaging 22/25 now, pretty decent.
 
I wish someone would make a 13, 14, or 16 inch after market barrel for the old ones. Lots of guys would dust them off and drag them out of the closets.
 
how do they compare?
I have owned a 12 gauge and 20 gauge BPS before. The BPS has some items stamped out of thinner steel like the slide release. The BPS is heavier, my 20 gauge BPS felt similar in weight to this 12 gauge M37. The LOP on the BPS seems longer, I have to stretch out to pump it. The BPS doesn't seem to fit me well at all, but the M37 comes up and points like an extension of my body.
 
how do they compare?
I have owned a 12 gauge and 20 gauge BPS before. The BPS has some items stamped out of thinner steel like the slide release. The BPS is heavier, my 20 gauge BPS felt similar in weight to this 12 gauge M37. The LOP on the BPS seems longer, I have to stretch out to pump it. The BPS doesn't seem to fit me well at all, but the M37 comes up and points like an extension of my body.

I experienced the same fit issue with my BPS's. I took 1/4" off of the butt and reinstalled the pads on my 12 and 10 gauge. Fit real well now. The 10 gauge is pushing 10 pounds (to be expected) but the 12 gauge is the sneaky one at well over 8 pounds with a 22" Upland Special barrel. Now that they fit and I don't have to stretch out to pump them they are nice guns. I feel there is no comparison between the BPS and Ithaca 37 except that they both have bottom eject. After a day with a BPS a field grade model 37 would feel like a waspy wand.

Darryl
 
To me the older 37 is a sleeper, meaning they are very under rated which is a good thing because it keeps the prices low. I like how narrow butt stock and the corn cob fore end is compare to a Mossberg 500 or Winchester model 12. The 37 has the history and had even fought in some of the same wars as the model 12. Bottom eject is way cool because it keeps all of me shells in a neat pile for reloading and I can't believe that no one mention the slam fire capability yet... I am a mess when it comes to slam fire but it is fun and adds another level of cool. My 37 is still my go to gun on the farm and with close to 180 to chose from, it saids a lot about the old Ithaca.
 
Love the bottom ejection too, and you can very easily load one in the chamber despite people saying you can't. The only feature I prefer on the BPS is the tang safety. I'm not sure how Browning gets the BPS to weigh as much as it does, the M37 is solid steel and it feels much lighter than the BPS.
 
Love the bottom ejection too, and you can very easily load one in the chamber despite people saying you can't. The only feature I prefer on the BPS is the tang safety. I'm not sure how Browning gets the BPS to weigh as much as it does, the M37 is solid steel and it feels much lighter than the BPS.

The weight difference is in the receiver size(length) and barrel wall thickness. I, too like the BPS tang safety.

Darryl
 
I have one in 20 gauge, I love shooting skeets with it and alot of my friends love it because it's so light to handle and quick to bring on target. Mine is quite old (1950's at the latest) and only takes 2.75" shells.


I have one of those too, I think mine is a 60s model.
 
I briefly had a 1957 model that I quickly fell in love with before it had a parts breakage that had me return it to the dealer.

I need to find another. ...I might even consider a new made field grade one someday if they are even imported. Wish I had jumped on one of the waterfowl ones when they were being cleared out for under $700 last fall. I just didn't appreciate at the time how lovely they were
 
I briefly had a 1957 model that I quickly fell in love with before it had a parts breakage that had me return it to the dealer.

I need to find another. ...I might even consider a new made field grade one someday if they are even imported. Wish I had jumped on one of the waterfowl ones when they were being cleared out for under $700 last fall. I just didn't appreciate at the time how lovely they were

Got this one off the EE for significantly less than that, I don't think the previous owner use it much at all because it looked NIB to me.
 
I briefly had a 1957 model that I quickly fell in love with before it had a parts breakage that had me return it to the dealer.

I need to find another. ...I might even consider a new made field grade one someday if they are even imported. Wish I had jumped on one of the waterfowl ones when they were being cleared out for under $700 last fall. I just didn't appreciate at the time how lovely they were

There are some reputable gunsmiths that hold many spare M37 Ithaca parts in inventory.
Gunco in Ottawa comes quickly to mind. (Too bad Mr. Ron Sharp is undergoing health care for cancer)
 
Back
Top Bottom