Kicking myself, massive moose.

Joe Sixpack

Member
EE Expired
Rating - 100%
3   0   0
Location
Sask
So we were hunting moose in northern Sask, hadn't seen anything all trip. We were walking an old clear cut that had about 15ft tall solid brush, and a long straight 20 yard wide path through it. We were walking and came to a T where another path joined ours. Saw something black about 400 yards down the path. Initially thought it was a bear. Looked with the scope, it was a cow. Then we see the bull.

Massive. 50" easily. The wind was right and they were walking directly towards us. We got low and watched them get closer. They were walking close to each other and directly towards us and the bull didn't offer a clean shot. The cow and the bull were never more than a couple feet apart. They got about 150 yards away and stopped. I had the gun up, had him in my cross hairs, but it was raining and about +2 degrees C and I was cold and shaking(from the adrenaline too). I was standing freehand, went down on one knee to see if that would help, no, still too shaky. Couldn't hold steady enough to take a clean shot. Waited for him to give me more of a target, even a quartering shot and I would have squeezed one off. He turned into the bush and we never saw him again. Hunted the area for one more day, didn't see him again. I've never seen a bull that big. He was high and wide and had front points that looked like they were 3 feet long. Beautiful orange tinted rack. Amazingly beautiful. Haunts me.

Spent every night thinking about whether I should have taken the shot. I had him in the crosshairs, but there was such a small target when he was facing directly towards me and if I wounded him, he could have gotten into the thick bush and we would have had fun finding him. Talking to people who have done a lot more moose hunting than I have tell me that moose with a non-lethal shot will go a few yards into the bush and lay down, not run for miles like a whitetail. Most have said I should have shot. I think I did the right thing, but damn, I'm seeing that guy in my dreams. I remember thinking how small a kill shot is on a frontal shot and that if I was at home shooting at a target freehand at 150yds, and was freezing cold in the rain, I likely wouldn't make the shot, and if you can't make it in ideal conditions at the range without the adrenaline, it shouldn't be done in the field. Plus the cow was basically right beside him and with me shivering and shaking, even though they were slightly apart, hitting her was a possibility too. Add into that a gun that had been bouncing around in the gun boot on my quad for a week, were the sights still bang on?...these were the things racing through my melon.

Still wish I had made the shot or had some shooting sticks with me, but the less you have to carry in the swampy muskeg crap, the better. There was nothing I could have used for a rest, and if I had gone prone, I wouldn't have been able to see him.

Tell me I did the right thing....I can't stop kicking myself for not taking the shot.
 
I had a situation with a huge whitetail buck a few years ago. Very similar.
I couldn't get steady, took too long to line-up the shot and when I finally did the bullet hit a damn twig and deflected.

I am haunted by that deer too... I'm haunted by a monster black bear... and umpteen other whitetails
 
Of course you did the right thing. If you were not comfortable in taking the shot, don't take it. That is what being a responsible hunter is all about.
 
Just think how big he'll be NEXT year! :D

If he makes it til next year...and I was shaking that much from seeing him this year...I'll likely go into convulsions and be completely incapacitated, be lying on the ground in the fetal position having seizures. I've downed many big whitetail bucks and calmed the buck fever, but seeing this guy, and being cold and wet, it was just ridiculous how much I was shaking. I got sweaty walking through the miles of muskeg to get to this clearing, and I just got the shivers. In hindsight, I should have shed some layers, but it was raining too, so it wouldn't have helped.

sealhunter, as far as using binos, I have a nice pair of them that I use for deer season, but where we hunted, it is so bloody mucky and thick and hard to get to, I figured the 16x on my scope would be good enough for checking things out at distance. Not ideal, but it works. The less to carry(and break or lose), the better. If we had gotten him, it would have been at least 12 hours of hard work getting him out...that was going through my head too.
 
Tell me I did the right thing....I can't stop kicking myself for not taking the shot.[/QUOTE]

You did not do the WRONG thing. You would be kicking yourself even harder if you had wounded that animal.
 
I'd be kicking myself too - but that doesn't mean you did the wrong thing. What you did (or didn't do) took tremendous restraint and I would question anyone who doesn't give you that. Good on you.

Oh, and how do you think he got to be that big?
 
I'd be kicking myself too - but that doesn't mean you did the wrong thing. What you did (or didn't do) took tremendous restraint and I would question anyone who doesn't give you that. Good on you.

Oh, and how do you think he got to be that big?

I went through a bad stage in my hunting life where I would get excited and pull the trigger when I saw hair in the scope. Well, not that bad, but close. About 7 or 8 years ago, I got a single shot Ruger #1 and learned to take my time and be sure of the shot. If I wasn't confident in the shot, I'd rather not shoot. My dad always hunted with a #1 and said it would be the best thing to get since you aren't thinking about the second or third shot because there isn't one. I haven't missed an animal with that gun yet, which is why I really am kicking myself, I've made much harder shots, but not under those same conditions. I guess you all are right, I just can't stop seeing that brute every time I close my eyes.
 
You did the right thing man :cool: . I had a similar encounter last week on my 8 day hunt (only not as big).

I was glassing for 4 days straight...nothing, not a damn thing was moving. 5th morning I returned to a ridge that has proved VERY profitable for our gang. I look down about 700 yards to another ridge and see a black spot. "Well I've been glassing black smudges all week and all they have been were stumps...but I gotta hit this one with the bino's JUST to be sure." Well there he was laying on the ridge all 35-40" of him...the shakes start (and this was the ONLY day I left my shooting sticks back at camp :jerkit: ). I had to get closer but I was on a 10 foot wide skid road with nothing but rasberry bushes, dried branches, egg shells, potato chips, silent car alarms ect ect on all sides of me. So I start slowly walking down the road hunched over. I get what I *thought* was 300-350 yards away and he makes me and starts lumbering for the bush..."F*ck...I gotta make a move...no big deal, I got a pine tree to rest off, I can do this." And my shot *was* nice and steady...but I grossly misjudged the distance. I fired 2 shots and both fell short.

My dad and I spent 1.5 hours looking for blood...nothing. And THANK god it was nothing...after I took the shot I felt ashamed at how irresponsible that shot was and what it would have been like for the moose if I'd have wounded it and never recovered it :( .

Rangefinder for next year and ALOT more practice behind the Sako...never again will I take a pot shot at a game animal...the thought of wounding it still lingers in my mind...

And that was about the hardest post I've ever had to make on here about me f*cking up :redface: .
 
We, too just got back from our moose hunt in N. Ab. We called in 5 different bulls, 4 times I could have shot, but every time, it just wasn't "right", in my opinion. My wife even bugs me about the one time, but I didn't like the angle, and when I shoot an animal, I want it dead with a capital D.
You didn't do the wrong thing, you did the right thing, as obviously at that moment you felt the shot, "just wasn't right".
Don't worry, they'll make more, and you'll have other chances.
 
Sounds to me like you made the right choice. Doesn't mean that it wasn't a tough choice, but a choice had to be made and you made the right one. It could have worked out if you had decided to shoot. Should have, could have, would have. It also could have worked out to be a disaster had you pulled the bang switch. Sounds like you made the responsible, level-headed, ethical decision for YOU and for THAT DAY and for THAT SITUATION. Never let anyone tell you different. Good on you.
 
Last saturday a buddy pushed a buck by me at about 100M running fully broadside. I had my BP rifle and was not comfortable at all with the shot so I let him go. Sure I might of got him but I might of gut shot and lost him as well. No regrets at all. As was said in previous posts doing the right thing is always best. Just imagine how you would of felt wounding and losing that huge bull.
 
Back
Top Bottom