If I overtightened them, which I did with double what you suggested and now can't get them off (I didn't use loctite though thank goodness), do you know if the rifle is still safe to use? If so I may shoot it for a bit and hope that the handguard screws all loosen on their own over time. Last time I used an allen key and applied a lot of torque to it but it still came loose with use. This time I used the FAT wrench set to 60in/lb and now I can't loosen them at all without stripping them.
The rifle is still safe to shoot, no problem there.
If I may suggest one more thing: do not unscrew/break torque with a FAT wrench (or any torque wrench).
Torque wrenches are calibrated tools and breaking torque with those will mess with their calibration.