I like my 16. Pretty much a matter of personal preference. I hunt in heavy cover so like the extra punch of a 16 without the weight of packing a 12. You have to pay attention, depending on where you live, as the shells are not as commonly available as 12 and 20 ga. For example the 100 count boxes you can pickup in 20 and 12 ga. at CT or similar outlet are not available. That is the only downside that comes to mind.