H59 is about the best you can have. Some say is busy but when you get use to it you can hold when others are taking valuable time dialing. It is as good as you can get on a reticle. My personal opinion only...
Take some time and shoot with it and you will see. The rest will say that there is better but they have likely not used the H59. Again, my personal opinion... shoot what you like how you like and forget the rest. H59 works for me.
I can make that call. Zoom to where you like. Reduce the zoom and you can still hold what you need or dial what you want. It gives me the flexibility to make the call and that helps make the shot. Other reticles will do the same if you work with them enough. The only thing I have every wanted on the h59 is to have a few mils above the line for hold under. Wind would be a non issue at that point...
I'm tickled pink with my P4LF reticle, clean and functional reticle, that being said my next optic is all but guranteed to have a horus reticle. It will take some getting used to but as stated here, once you get on it, there is no touching it. At least not yet.
Horus guys I am curious your take on the h59 vs tremor 2 reticles?
Interested in feedback here as well.....used an H59 once and found it a bit much, but at the same time understand why it's so good. Also heard that the Tremor 2 is picking up some momentum.
Next scope will be one or the other.
If you aren't planning to compete and shoot on the clock, and dialing for all the distances, the Xmas tree reticles have limited use. They do work well as others have suggested but may not be that useful to your current needs.
You may find that a Hash Mark reticle ... ie windage markings, is all that you need.
Regardless, choose a reticle that matches the click unit of the scope.. mil/mil or MOA/MOA. Given the distances you want to reach out to, internal elevation adjustment is a very important need and I would look at scopes with at least 60mins to reach out... more elevation travel will be useful and many scopes offer 80 to 100mins without costing the moon.
Tracking and return to zero will be very important and here some brands do better then others. Most of the scopes mentioned are over $2K and work but not sure if you were planning such a budget?
with a more modest budget, getting a quality scope with good optics, tracking/mechanicals and reticle become more tricky but more options are coming online each year.
The 6.5 Creedmoor and bullets in the 140/142gr range have no issue reaching out. Some bullets are transonic stable, others are not so that becomes something to consider when reaching way out.
Good luck with your journey
Jerry
Thanks Jerry, I am looking for a top tier scope. I like the idea of buy once cry once.. I was set on a S&B for the longest time but I'm not a huge fan of the PLF,, I think I prefer the .2 mil wind markings on the Kahles skmr. Now I'm thinking K624I SKMR/3 vs Nightforce ATACR f1 Mil-C, both hove .2 reticles. K624I has less elevation range (will only be an issue if I move this scope onto a true ELR rig, but I may not have the money for a new scope in the future) but I worry about Nightforce's Mechanicaly calibrated clicks and ruggedness compared to the Kahles.