Looking for my first Revolver

jcfougere

jcfougere

New member
Rating - 100%
9   0   0
Location
Kimberley BC
Hello folks

I tried to find a classifieds section and couldn't find one so I apologize ahead of time if this is the wrong place to post!

I've had my RPAL for a few years now and I'm finally financially stable enough to purchase my first revolver.

I am in Ontario and will be using the firearm for range practice. I would love to find a used firearm because I believe they don't make things today like they used to, and because I'll save a few dollars and someone can make a few dollars selling something they no longer use.

I've done a bit of brand research and seem to find Colt the highest recommended in revolvers. S&W and Ruger also turn up a lot.

I would prefer a DA.

I have a large hand, and a strong grip, and would like something with a bit longer barrel then the standard 4" since I will be using it at the range and not for up close self defense as you would see in the USA. I know a 5-6" barrel will help me in the accuracy department, and that is my goal, accuracy and the fun that comes with becoming accurate with a new firearm.

If anyone could make suggestions on which revolver might be right for me, or has one to sell, please let me know.

James.
 
I just bought a Ruger GP100 chambered in .357 magnum and I absolutely love this gun. Its a stainless 6" and was just north of $750 after taxes in.
 
jcfougere said:
If anyone could make suggestions on which revolver might be right for me.
Click to expand...
The "right one" will be the one that fits you best and feels best in your hand. If you can, handle some at a store or better yet, try to get your hands on a couple at a range to run a few rounds through. They will always shoot better if they fit right and are comfortable. You can also change grips to suit a larger hand.
 
Centrefire :)

.357special or mag or .45

I haven't done much caliber research yet.

I'm hoping for suggestions there as well. I won't get in to reloading so the cost of reloads doesn't matter to me. I won't get out shooting often enough that cost/caliber is a factor.

Something that doesn't blow my arm off, but that also still carries stopping power and accuracy at distance. I don't mind shooting .300win mag from my rifle, but I prefer the feel of a .308 if that helps. Kind of apples and oranges comparing rifle to handgun.

James.
 
I'll second the GP100 in .357 (you can also shoot less expensive .38 special in a 357 Magnum) You could also look at the newer AlfaProj revolvers that recently surfaced in Canada. They are priced lower than the GP100 and seem to have some decent reviews.

If you are looking for used, you need to sign up for the EE (Equipment Exchange) and keep an eye out. Might find a decent deal on a Smith, Ruger etc.
 
jcfougere said:
As a note, I do like the idea of adjustable sights. Not sure if that severely limits me though.
Click to expand...

You need to register with the EE Electronic Exchange to see the adds.. the how to is at the top of page.

For getting started you could not find a better revolver for basic shooting skills and affordable practice than a Smith & Wesson 617 (A Classic and high quality shooter that keeps it's value)
 
Thanks guys, I've requested to join the EE group to start looking.

Great suggestions I like the look of the 617 a lot, and the gp100 is pretty similar as well. Both look to have long barrels and adjustable sights too.

2 very good firearms in the running.
 
jcfougere said:
Thanks guys, I've requested to join the EE group to start looking.

Great suggestions I like the look of the 617 a lot, and the gp100 is pretty similar as well. Both look to have long barrels and adjustable sights too.

2 very good firearms in the running.
Click to expand...

The 617 is 22 cal you know..
 
Are you located anywhere near Windsor? I would be happy to bring you out to try my revolver (S&W 586 .357 Mag). I am always happy to convert someone to the Church of Revolverology. Otherwise, I suggest a used Smith.
 
As ruger prices are rising and S&W prices haven't (yet) I would whole heartly advise you to pick up a S&W 686. Much better trigger, forged frame and looks better (IMO)

Ruger is a good gun (I have one) but smith is just a bit better. ;)

Good luck and welcome to revolverdom.
 
Given the price of commercial ammo I'd strongly suggest you stick with a .357Mag gun so you have the option of reasonably cheap .38Spl and the occasional box of .357Mag rounds for some big recoil giggles.

Just for the heck of it go around to a gun shop and ask for pricing on .38Spl, .357Mag, .44Special if they have any, and .44Mag and .45Colt. I suspect you'll quickly settle on a .357Mag revolver so you can shoot .38Spl with some optional .357Mag now and then. The rest all cost stupid amounts of money.

And save your brass. Sooner or later and assuming you break into shooting handgun competitions of any sort you'll be glad you did.
 
My vote would be for a S&W 686, which is what I bought as my first centrefire handgun. I found mine (no dash) with a factory ported barrel on the EE for under $700. It's still my favorite shooter compared to my friend's GP100, which is very similar quality except for the trigger, and my semi-autos. Being able to shoot 38SPL makes it cheaper for practice, and 357Mag is just a pile of fun.

686 no dash (1980): regular production started
686-1 (1986): radius stud package, floating hand
686-2 (1987): change hammer nose, bushing and associated parts
686-3 (1988): new yoke retention system
686-4 (1993): Change rear sight leaf, drill and tap frame, change extractor, introduce Hogue grips
686-5 (1997): Change frame design to eliminate cylinder stop stud, eliminate serrated tangs, change to MIM hammer with floating firing pin, change to MIM trigger, change internal lockwork
686-6 (2001): Internal hammer and trigger key lock
686-7 (2002): Performance center version in .38 Super Automatic

Hope you enjoy whatever you go with,
GMC
 
Thanks everyone! The 686 sounds great, especially since it can load the 38spl and the .357mag ammo!

I didn't realize the S&W 617 was a .22, that'll take it out of the running.

WRH: I'm located in Lindsay, so Windsor would be a be a bit of a drive, but I would take you up on that later on in the growing season when things slow down in farm country here :) Thank you very much for the offer.
 
No offense intended here but it seams like you really do not know exactly what you want. I would suggest spending some time at your range. Try some different options and narrow down what you are interested in. I think I can speak for most when I say most club members would gladly let you squeeze off a few rounds with their guns. I myself normally travel with 5-6 hand guns when I go to my range, I have let many people try them out. Good luck with your search.
 
You're right bydabeav, I haven't fired many handguns as a whole, and it would be great to get to test a bunch and find out which I like best.

I'm currently searching for gun clubs in my area to join so wish me luck in finding some of those friendlies with lots of revolvers :)
 
JC, I see you have posted a WTB ad for a 686. Unless you have your heart set on stainless, you should be open to the blued version, Model 586. I picked mine up used for $550 plus tax and it is great. Either way, I wish you luck in your search.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom