M&P9 VS Glock 17

J

JoeOnePack

CGN frequent flyer
Rating - 97%
162   5   1
Location
GTA
Hey there.

Sorry if this is an overdone or pointless topic, but I just can't decide between the 2. I need someone to push me either way.

I am deciding on a handgun. Keep in mind, this will be my ONLY handgun, please don't say "buy both" because I don't want or need both lol. I want one gun that I can rely on, that I don't have to worry about functioning. This will be a range gun and will be locked up beside my bed as well. Reliability/durability are important. I am sure eventually I will buy more, but I want to do it up right the first time.

Heres what I plan to do, and before people tell me its not practical, stupid or what ever, I'm doing it because I can, and because its fun :p

- Glock 17 OR M&P9
- Milled slide w/ Trijicon RMR
- Refinish slide either FDE or Tungsten type color KG Gun-Kote.
- Trijicon Suppressor Sights
- Crimson trace laser grips
- Surefire X300 w/ DG switch
- Stippling (grip reduction for Glock)


M&P:
- I like the grip a little better compared to stock glock
- Like the looks more
- I like its crimson grip better as it fits right into the grip, its also much more streamline, less bulky.
- More 1911 like.
- Have heard some widespread issues with M&P9 accuracy issues on newer models.

Glock:
- Proven track record, very reliable
- Consistent with accuracy from what I have read
- Grip is a little awkward, points a little high (can stipple/reduce grip myself)
- New crimson grip wraps around front interfering with DG switch. Would have to use older more bulky CT grip

I was set on the M&P45 at first, but 9mm is easier to shoot and cheaper.
I was then leaning towards the M&P9 and now I'm leaning a little towards the G17 gen 3. This is killing me.

I can get an M&P9 right now in near new condition for $525 with 2 mags from a member on here. I don't see any used Glock 17's.

What to do?
 
I have both :D

The only way for you to determine which one to buy, is to shoot both. See which one fits in your hand the best and gives you the best result.
 
I have a Gen 4 Glock 17 and a M&P40. When just holding each of them, I like the feel of the M&P. However, when I shoot the M&P, the palm swell is too high compared to the Glock and it actually hurts my palm.

I agree the grip angle of the Glock feels a little weird but it grows on you. I had a chance to hold the XD9 and that felt pretty good. Slim grips, seemingly better grip angle and no fat palm swell. Maybe check that one out too.

I just took the TDSA Advance Pistol 1 course this past weekend and shot over 800 rounds through the Glock with no problems. If anything, the grip was too....grippy.

Allan
 
Forget all the extra doo-dads, and new finishes. Spend that cash on ammo. If the M&P feels more natural, then your choice is made. Learn to shoot it well and only then think about making changes or buying another gun. By then you should be able to make an informed decision on what works for you.
 
I'd get a glock. From what I have seen the m&p just doesn't have the durablity that glock has. In my black badge course 2 people had the pro version and the rear sight came loose on one and on the other the pin for the trigger safety backed out some how. Reliablity wasn't that great either due to the mags. They have problems seating when there is one in the chamber. This is just my opinion though. Get the one you like.
 
It seems to me that if you can get a really good deal on the M&P and you like the way it feels, that's the way to go. I'm on an American M&P forum and I certainly haven't heard anything about accuracy problems in the 9mm. One thing you haven't mentioned is the respective feel of the two pistols' triggers. You'd be well advised to actually shoot examples of both and see if that changes your mind.

I'm a big M&P fan, but I'd never advise someone to buy a gun they didn't like or had any doubts about. If worse comes to worst, you can always flip whatever you first choose and buy the other. Heaven knows lots of us have done just that...
 
I have to vote for the glock, IMO its the better gun out of the box. But condomboy put it best, go pick them both up and pick and whichever one you like best is the one you should go with.
 
anark said:
I have a Gen 4 Glock 17 and a M&P40. When just holding each of them, I like the feel of the M&P. However, when I shoot the M&P, the palm swell is too high compared to the Glock and it actually hurts my palm.
Click to expand...
While I like the M&P better than a Glock myself there's a lot of truth in what anark mentions here. If you're buying a handgun to shoot well it's more important how well you can shoot it than how it feels. It never liked how the Glock looked or felt in my hand but I could shoot them quite well. If you're buying a handgun just for fun at the range (which is an OK reason to buy a gun too) then looks and feel are fine to take into account.
 
I got a G17 gen 3 rtf2 after shooting Glocks, baby eagles, kimber 1911's, SA and DA revolvers and all manner of other pistols at my club. I found the G17 to be the most accurate and natural for me to handle. Everyone is different, shoots different, different style etc... just have to try them and see which you like best. Worst case you get them both. ;)
 
Had both as well, more than one of each in fact. I liked M&P better than gen3 Glocks, but after gen4 came out I sold the M&P, thats all I can say.
 
TDC said:
Seek professional training before you waste money on after market crap.

Tdc
Click to expand...

I'm not trying to be a professional, I'm trying to have fun... I dont think having all these things will make me an amazing shooter either, so don't get that Idea.

Thanks everyone for their responses so far.
 
I couldn't even remember how many times I hear " I only need one gun" and end up buy another and another. Mind you what ever you do to the finishing or grip and you will hardly to sell them once you don't like it anymore.

Trigun
 
One thing I might add--make sure you're completely happy with whatever you get and plan to hold onto it long-term before you do any serious permanent modifications like stippling or a grip reduction. Any modification will reduce the resale value of your handgun.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom