Man eats goose that walked into his yard

Are we all going to ignore the judge? That judge was forced to hear that case, and a tip of the hat for how they dealt with it. Nice seeing common sense prevail for a change.

Agreed. He’s the only one in this story that has a nick of common sense… Rare to see a judge using common sense in this day and age…
 
I would have said it was a stray domestic goose that was eating my garden. What am I, an ornithologist? I'm not much on eating wild animals that are acting funny though, not really a safe thing to do.
 
I suppose the King's servant could have attempted the "Protection of Property" defence under paragraph 31(1)(b) of the Fish and Wildlife Conservation Act, 1997, S.O. 1997, c. 41.

Protection of property

31 (1) If a person believes on reasonable grounds that wildlife is damaging or is about to damage the person’s property, the person may, on the person’s land,

(a) harass the wildlife for the purpose of deterring it from damaging the person’s property; or

(b) capture or kill the wildlife. 1997, c. 41, s. 31 (1).

It would be a huge stretch and waterfowl doesn't fall under this anyways.
 
Years ago Golfed with fellows that were regulars at prospect lake.gc in Victoria. Tried shooing flock of.canada geese that were grazing on the front of the tee box. Back before you walk back to tees. So one guy just tees off. You guessed it, worm burner, smoked a goose right in the head.

He took it home to eat it. Guts crawling with worms. So he buried it in the garden. Got the attention of coons. No $500 fine though.

I have shot 1000s of geese in my life, never seen one full of worms.
 
“wildlife” means an animal that belongs to a species that is wild by nature, and includes game wildlife and specially protected wildlife; (“animal sauvage”)

https://www.ontario.ca/laws/statute/97f41#BK1

Migratory birds cannot be killed under FWCA "protection of property" regulation without a federal permit.

Similar how, up until last year, in ON, it was not an offence to allow migratory birds to spoil or be wasted. Luckily the ON FWCA was updated to include migratory birds.

Also, deer, moose and elk cannot be killed under the "protection of property" regulation without a permit from the OMNR.
 
Migratory birds cannot be killed under FWCA "protection of property" regulation without a federal permit.

Similar how, up until last year, in ON, it was not an offence to allow migratory birds to spoil or be wasted. Luckily the ON FWCA was updated to include migratory birds.

Also, deer, moose and elk cannot be killed under the "protection of property" regulation without a permit from the OMNR.

When I lived in Ontario I was named on 4 landowners permits to kill nuisance geese and cranes. That permit was issued by an agricultural agency of the government. I can't recall which now? It's been too many years.
 
“wildlife” means an animal that belongs to a species that is wild by nature, and includes game wildlife and specially protected wildlife; (“animal sauvage”)

https://www.ontario.ca/laws/statute/97f41#BK1

The original story is out of Lethbridge, so not governed by the Ontario Wildlife Act you're quoting. Each province has its own Wildlife Act, except migratory birds, which fall under the jurisdiction of Environment Canada,but still enforced by provincial CO's. As waterfowler mentioned, some animals can't be killed in defense of property. Here in Manitoba, cougar is actually on that list, along with most wild ungulates.
It's a bit of a strange legislation. People shoot skunks and red squirrels in their yard all the time, yet technically they're furbearers with seasons.
 
Last edited:
The original story is out of Lethbridge, so not governed by the Ontario Wildlife Act you're quoting. Each province has its own Wildlife Act, except migratory birds, which fall under the jurisdiction of Environment Canada,but still enforced by provincial CO's. As waterfowler mentioned, some animals can't be killed in defense of property. Here in Manitoba, cougar is actually on that list, along with most wild ungulates.
It's a bit of a strange legislation. People shoot skunks and red squirrels in their yard all the time, yet technically they're furbearers with seasons.

Hi,

Thank you... I stand corrected! :)

If a cougar was about to harm my pet dog or domestic cat, one would think I could protect my own property with the force required!
 
Another Tim tok disaster. Should give your kids a “safe handling” course for their phones before you let them own one. Make it up off the
Prove and acts principle. :)
 
Hi,

Thank you... I stand corrected! :)

If a cougar was about to harm my pet dog or domestic cat, one would think I could protect my own property with the force required!

Everything is fair game when it comes to protecting pets or family members, whether legal or not. Just don't take a video/pics or talk about it.
The cougar reference is more in regard to protection of livestock.
 
Hi,

Thank you... I stand corrected! :)

If a cougar was about to harm my pet dog or domestic cat, one would think I could protect my own property with the force required!

in Sk, there has been a few shot over the years in the SW as they are starting to get too aggressive. One was stalking a young boy walking up the drive from school bus.
Skunks I try to leave alone, but damn dogs don't listen.
 
Another Tim tok disaster. Should give your kids a “safe handling” course for their phones before you let them own one. Make it up off the
Prove and acts principle. :)

Perhaps, an annual school course for students on the do's and do not's on the Internet would be good! My generation did not have these issues, but these youngsters need some help with the new digital universe.
 
Lol .... once the goose realize .... how many goose do you think those migrants will get with machetes?

Zero!!!!!!!

Those city goose are not afraid of humans because they are not hunted ... and the country goose know better ....

But the city goose can learn quickly .....


What a waste in taxpayer's money ....

You’re missing the point.
 
Lefties like to say things like what if someone stole bread because they were hungry? Guess it doesn’t apply to geese lol

But there is a growing ant meat-eating trend out there.
 
I had a goose land on my balcony. Dogs brought it to me. People saw, got reported, I even called the authorities. Apparently, it happens a lot, and she was glad I didn't waste any edible meat.
I'm in Ontario.
 
Back
Top Bottom