The pressure is not the issue with the 7.62x51 surplus ammo. We have found that the brass used in some surplus ammo sticks whereas the vast majority of commercial manufactured ammo brass does not. This is our experience, not BS. Furthermore, a customer recently infomred us that 7.62x51 IVI ammo worked great yet some other surplus they tried did not.
Further to the OP isssue. We have had mixed reports of 6.5 Grendel in the Renegade. Some cusotmers have had success however many more have not. We regret that we cannot be of more assitance beyond recommending some of the ideas shared in this thread. I think the assesment that the straight walled case does create a greater bearing surface that cannot be suffciently broken with the primary extraction system that we have on the Renegade is sound.
An alternative we can offer for those seeking a deer huniting caliber, the Renegade is now available in 300BLk with a 1:10 twist which is optimal for 125gr to 150gr ammo. A 16" 300BLK Renegade is very accurate and will deliver sufficient energy out to ranges of 300m. We have 16" 300BLK rifles, barrels, and complete upper receivers available right now for anyone interested in this caliber. If you are looking for something to harvest larger game like Bear, Elk, or Moose, we offer the Maverick in 308 Win and soon 6.5 Creedmoor.