Mushroom Identification: Shaggy Mane or Scaley Ink Cap??

[Mount Sweetness]

These are the first of the Ink Cap family that I have found.

They were growing in a grass lawn, no trees near by, growing in clusters, plenty of them. I took a few caps to try a spore test and in less than 24hrs the caps went completely to ink. The stems are 3 to 5 inches long and are hollow, I did not see a ring on any of them. the flakes on the cap seem to be somewhat beige in colour. The gills are light brown slightly pink when young, the older ones are dark brown/black.

I had hoped that these were Shaggy Mane, but I am unsure after reading up on Scaley Ink Caps and Alcohol Ink Caps.

What are these?? Anybody eat Scaley Ink Caps?

p.s. that is my new beagle pup...Darby Duke!!

 

[Gatehouse]

Looks liek shaggy manes, but they go all black and inky, too. Gotta get shaggy manes when they are young.

 

[Mount Sweetness]

The problem is that Shappy Manes, Scaley ink caps and alcohol ink caps.....they all look so very similar. Can anyone identify for sure?

 

[Wrong Way]

They All taste great....just skip the beer when you cook them

 

[Ruger007]

Are these pictures of the same mushrooms? Pics 2 & 3 sure look like shaggy manes but picture 1 looks like inky's

 

[Mount Sweetness]

yes, all pictures of the same mushrooms

 

[Mount Sweetness]

They look a lot like these:
http://www.wildmanstevebrill.com/Mushrooms.Folder/Alcohol Inky.html