My First .22 LR Bolt Action - Ruger American Rimfire vs Savage Mk II BRJ (Or Other)?

SKennedy

New member
EE Expired
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Hi everyone!

I'm in the market for my first .22 LR bolt gun and for weeks I have been on the fence about which make/model I want to buy. I'm also conflicted in terms of pricepoint. I was hoping you could help me make up my mind.

I have been shooting for years now. I was in the CF for 8 years and shot everything from 5.56 to 7.62 to slugs and 9mm. I am now in law enforcement and therefore have a lot of experience shooting pistols. At home I have my own guns that I occasionally practice with and have shot a lot of friends rifles. All this is to say that while I am sure i'm a bit rusty, I'm an experienced shooter. Moving on...

The way I see it, every gun owner should own a .22. It's that gun you take to the range to work on your marksmanship principals. It's that spend-all-day-at-the-range-for-twenty-bucks gun. It's a staple for many, many reasons, and unfortunately, it's the gun that i've been lacking for as long as i've been shooting :(

The thing is, the rifle I buy will serve multiple purposes. I want to plink with it at the range. I want to hunt small game. I want to be able to take it into the mountains for a day or two on those camping trips I love so much and not have to worry about anything breaking. I also want to teach my wife to shoot with it. As much as I love hammering targets with my .308, the price of ammo is definitely not conducive to teaching a new shooter, nor is the caliber very inviting to some beginners...

I guess you could say that i'm looking for a good 'ole fashioned mountain gun. Reliable, reasonably accurate, durable, sturdy and an all-round fun time.

Over the last 2-3 weeks I have been doing my best to research the top .22 bolt guns on the market right now, and throughout my research, 2 manufacturers have stood out in my mind: Ruger and Savage. I also hear great things about CZ, but haven't seen a lot of info around about their guns, nor have I seen any at any of the dealerships I've been to. (I live on the east coast.) There's also Browning and Remington, but what I have heard over and over and over again is that while they're good rifles, they're just way to expensive for what they are. So with all this in consideration, between the Ruger and Savage line, I've further narrowed it down to the 2 models I like the most: The Ruger American Rimfire or the Savage Mk II BRJ.


My observations about the Ruger American: (I have not held this gun yet, and my opinions may change when I do.)

+ Durability. I hear good things.
+ Loads of positive reviews.
+ Cheaper than the BRJ.
+ I love the magazine.
+ Has iron sights so I don't have to put a scope on it the day I buy it.
+ I haven't been able to confirm this, but (I think) everything but the caliber is identical to the Ruger American Bolt Action in .308? I hope to purchase and graduate my wife to the American .308 after she learns to shoot a .22, and doing it on a rifle that feels nearly identical would be great for the muscle memory and the learning experience.

- I've heard this is a very good budget rifle, but i'm just not sure i'll be satisfied with the build quality. I've seen a few people saying that the body was wobbly. At this point that's my only concern. I think I prefer the black synthetic to the colored wood synthetic of the BRJ, but I may change my mind when I see the gun in person.


My observations about the BRJ: (I have held this gun, it looks and feels great.)

+ Craftsmanship seems excellent
+ Smooth bolt action
+ I hear great things about the quality and accuracy of Savage guns, especially in recent years.
+ While I haven't made up my mind about whether or not I like it yet, the wife loved the coloring of the wood. She doesn't know anything about rifles, but she almost instantly picked this one out of a dozen others sitting in the display case based on the coloring alone. The fact that she likes it and is eager to use it is a big plus as far as i'm concerned.

- I despise the magazine.
- No iron sights, and cost is about $600 for the gun alone.
- Not sure what I personally feel about the coloring.
- There's not much on the internet about these guns. I'm not sure if there's a good reason for it or if they are actually just hidden jems like most of the few reviews I have seen about them seem to indicate.


I have spoken to various gun dealers and as soon as I mention the word ".22" they start walking over to the Ruger section. I guess this is to be expected given the popularity of the 10/22. However, when I mention that i'm looking for a bolt gun they sometimes end up recommending a Savage. I guess a lot of people think that Ruger makes the better semi auto while Savage makes the better bolt action.

In terms of buying philosophy: I'm not sure if I should just go cheap and save the money I don't spend on that inevitable .308 purchase later on down the road, or if I should get something a little pricier and better quality. After all, it should be a gun that I have for at least the next 10 years if I take care of it properly, not to mention the enjoyment I'll get out of it during all that time, so why not spend an extra few hundred dollars and get something nice?

I'm willing to pay up to $800 for the gun by itself, as long as it comes with iron sights and I don't need to put a scope on it in order to properly aim at anything the first time I use it. For something like the BRJ without iron sights, $550 - $600 is probably my limit.

I want another .308 as much as the next guy, but I get the feeling that most of my time spent shooting in the future will be spent with the .22. Either for quality time with the family, or because I love to shoot ammo that doesn't break the relatively small bank that I have access to for my shooting hobby.

What do you think of either of these guns?

If you wouldn't suggest either of these rifles to suit my needs or interests, what would you suggest instead?

Your advice is appreciated,
Thank you for your time!
 
Given the budget mentioned, I would strongly recommend a CZ452 Lux first i.e. if you can quickly find one or the followng target version of the CZ455 or a CZ455 Lux (this model will have a shorter barrel compared to the other two).....

http://store.prophetriver.com/cz-455-22lr-training-rifle-beechwood-bl-24-8/

You will find the overall build quality + excellent accuracy performance in a single package. The rifles mentioned all come with excellent quality iron sights, and in particular, the military style tangent sight visible in the image (the CZ452 has the same rear sight as well) that has stood up to the test since BRNO (predecessor to CZ) first put that on it's rimfire product during the early 60s.

The other brands mentioned within your post will be accurate, however, the attributes will end right there .....
 
I will second any CZ .22LR product. They are amazing from what I can tell you. I have a CZ455 in .17HMR (I know, different caliber, but same action and such) and it is the best rim fire I have ever fired and/or owned. If you spend the money on it you will get what you deserve. That's my opinion anyways...
 
The CZ455 lux sure is a beautiful gun, thank you for pointing it out. I have seen the regular CZ455 and i'm kind of hung up in the numbers and names of the CZ line, but I distinctly remember not really liking it that much. The lux, however, looks great. I can't believe I didn't see this until now. I'll definitely keep this one in mind. Thanks!
 
The number of people who own CZ rimfire rifles and the number of these rifles that end up in the EE should tell you something
 
I'm a savage fan to be honest. I've held the Ruger and played with them. I personally did not like it. It feels much cheaper than the synthetic savages.
Cz has a great line up and the 455 an take multiple barrels
As much as I love bolt guns another choice is the Henry lever gun. Easy to carry. Accurate. Reliable. Fun and just seems right on camping trips.
Other than the bmags I haven't come across a savage that wouldn't shoot moa with certain loads
 
Another vote for the CZ's here. Nothing on the shelf compares.

I have owned a MKII in the plain jane configuration, it is an accurate gun but ugly, and it fit me very poorly. I am also not a fan of the flimsy magazine release on some models.

And no offence, but why do you need a "mountain rifle" for PEI?
 
I can give you some info about the ruger American, I have owned one for about 1 year. I just use it to practice my technique and plink with the kids.

I got it for a couple of reasons. One of the main one’s is what you are suggesting. I had a ruger American 308 and wanted something similar as a practice rifle. I ended up getting the 308 as it fitted my so well in the shop. I ended up selling the 308 as I am now using a semi for hunting but I still have the 22lr.

The other thing I liked about the RA22 is that the iron sights are good and it’s easy to take a scope off and use the irons as the mounting base is part of the receiver. The other thing is that it comes with 2 different comb heights one for using iron sights and one for the scope. I also found it easy to purchase an additional stock insert. I bought a full size one and then I purchased a high comb with a short LOP so that my kids can use it. This comes in handy, I am going shooting tomorrow and about 1 hr ago swabbed the stock insert around so I have the long lop for me. If I had to do it again I would probably buy the compact model and purchase a longer LOP stock insert, but the model I have balances well, have not tried the compact model. Also love the ruger rotary magazine.

The RA22 is similar to the RA308 in terms of the safety and trigger are the same. The stocks are close but you will certainly notice the difference when holding each. I am happy with the RA22 with no plans to sell it. Certainly a nice gun for the price. It is the only bolt gun 22 I have owned so have no experience with the other makes out there.
 
Go with what your heart wants and wife that is the Savage.They need nothing out of the box to perform well.The accu trigger is simply amazing,can't say that about a CZ trigger.I bought a Savage Mark ii BV in the spring and liked it so much I had to get its big brother the TR.These guns just plain work and always go bang.Why bother with open sites as these rifles are such tack drivers they beg for optics.You say your budget is $800 for full boat retail I am into my BV and Vortex cross fire ii 4-16x50 for $700 rings incuded.The TR and crossfire ii 6-24x50 BDC reticle was just over $900 shipped from Praire Gun Traders.Nothing like shooting ritz crackers at 100-120 yds.Clays at 130yds right thru the centre with minimags.I love these guns,only thing extra required is a few 10 shot mags.If your really set on irons just get the mark ii G for $250 and spend the rest on a few mags and lots of different ammo to try.CCI and SK std plus work well as does the Aguila SUB and std.
wsa834.jpg

x36djs.jpg

2l9pedv.jpg

50 yd targets with the BV
 
Another vote for CZ. They've got the magic sauce and they pour it all over their rifles before leaving the factory!

I was out with my 452 Varmint this morning shooting CCI "Choot'ems", or mini-mags, and it was windy. The gusty-blustery wind that's hard to predict. I was doing mostly 50y grouping but shot a couple 5 shot groups at 100 and one ten-shot group. The two five shot groups were just under 2" and about 3". The ten-shot group was almost exactly 2". That rifle just continues to amaze me!

I also have a Henry "Golden Boy" and I have to admit that it is a REALLY fun little gun. Lever and pump guns are something special. It's like working a really slick bolt on a bolt-action, but better because there's more mechanical feel to it. Very satisfying. The Henry has worked flawlessly after more than 6000 rounds through it. Very accurate and if it's going to be shared with family members then for a "fun gun" I nominate the Henry!
 
I'd also look at a Browning BL-22 if you want a lever-action and want something a little nicer than the Henry. It's about the only Browning I can think of that I'd really like to own. If you can shoulder one I recommend it. They have a really short-throw action. I can't remember at the moment but I think it has a 33 degree throw. The Henry is around 90 I'm sure. For quick follow-up shots the BL-22 can't be beat!
 
I'm in at 11 to suggest the Cee Zed..it will shoot very respectable groups with American Eagle HP ammo and it will also do well with CCI HP or Velocitors or CCI quick shok segmenting ammo if squirrels are in the picture.
They seem to shoot very well in my hands and I am far from a marksman, but minute of gopher with any of the mentioned ammo and you are good to go.
Weaver Rimfire Scopes or Leupolds have also been my favorites on these guns.
The only pia is finding rings for the guns some are 3/8'' or 11mm dovetail and buying rings online only to find they do not quite fit sucks.
Tight Groups and Have Fun,
Rob
 
i have both the Ruger Rimfire and a Savage MKII BTVLSS which is similar to what your look at though the BTVLSS is one more step up i think from the one you mentioned.

if im to recommend one over the other its the ruger.

why?
half the price of the savage and the magazine.
the ruger i picked up brand new for $315 at my local gun store and i was out that same day in -24 plinking away with not one hiccup, really nice open sites.
gun is solid, cycles good and you have a Ruger BX-01 magazine which is by far the best 22 magazine on the market today.

i picked up the savage as i wanted a nice mid range bolt gun.
and it is a really nice mid range bolt gun.
its twice the price of the Ruger and you cant shoot it without a scope.
so over $600 and another $100 + depending for some optics, and the magazines are no great hell.

ive had the savage twice as long as ive had the ruger and the ruger has been to the range 20 times more then the savage.

oh, and i also have a Ruger American Centerfire and you are right, the stocks are pretty much identical.
so they would help you with the transition from the rimefire to the centerfire.

my recommendation, pick up the Ruger Rimefire and have some fun!
then pick up a 10/22 and since they use the same magazine your laughing!
then as money permits pick up a Ruger Ranch in .223 or .243 for the next step up.
then once your good and ready go get the same in 308.
simple and easy!
 
Another vote for cz which is by far a nicer quality, but savage makes an accurate rifle as well. I've never handled or shot the new ruger americans, but I'd buy a 10/22 before one of them anyways... why delay the inevitable? EVERYONE has a 10/22! way more fun for newbies too.
 
I bought the RAR a year ago. It's been a great addition to my collection. Well built. Problem free. Accurate. I give it a very strong recommendation.
 
First off, CZ has wonderful and accurate .22's. so it's a no brainer.
Ruger is reliable and made in the USA and all of my Rugers (10/22 included) are great guns and accurate. So if you want to save a bit and never look back the Ruger will be a happy choice. You can enjoy it with iron sights or put a nice red dot on it (holo sun HS403 series) and add to your enjoyment while keeping it in your cost range.
The savage you are referring to is a heavy barrel I think. Makes it even more accurate but adds a lot of weight for shooting. Off hand and letting the fam use.i rarely shoot out past 50 yards with my .22's so any type of expensive glass for a tack driver like the savage seems like a waste. Savage makes other models that are much less expensive that are accurate. Even my 5yr olds savage rascal can hit an apple at 50 yards off hand.
Since someone mentioned Henry... I also have a standard H001 lever, I can hit dimes at 30-40 yards on a bench and it's fun to use and pretty to boot!

In short, go for the fun factor instead of spending too much on a .22.
Hope that helps:)
 
Back
Top Bottom