I can't tell you about the .357 but a buddy went and bought the 1892 in .44 mag a few weeks ago against my advice. I have many levers from Winchester, Marlin, Henry, Savage and Rossi and I have handled some Chiappas and their quality is just sub par IMO. Anyway, I finally went over to see it and being a real newbie (his second gun and he's 51) he was talked into the tactical all black 1892 with the wood stocks painted with rock guard. I had to drag out of him what he paid and he grudgingly said $1100 and admitted he wasn't happy with the quality after getting it home. The action was very sticky and tight which will likely fix itself but the edges on the receiver were quite sharp and the wood to metal fitment was reminiscent of the early Remlins. What really pissed him off was that he managed to scrape off a nice long hunk of the rockguard paint on top of the stock with his fingernail leaving an ugly glaring patch displaying the white garbage wood below. I would save the money or buy a Rossi for around the same amount. I have a stainless Rossi 1892 in .44 with 16" barrel that is one of my "never sell" rifles. And shame on Sail for talking a newbie into such a crap deal!