Best bullet for 1:9...................260 Rem
I have learned a lot since asking about twist rates and have still not decided....what is best.
To date, I am convinced that the 1:9 twist will handle most bullets ranging from 107 gr to 140....depending upon the length of the bullet. For instance, a "match/varmint" profile in a light (107 gr) bullet is long enough to perform well with the 1:9 twist. That seems to apply to all the "pointed profile" bullets up to 140 gr..... After that, a 1:8 twist would be best. Given that not many 260 owners will use bullets over 140gr, I suspect the 1:9 is quite adequate at stabilizing most bullets. "Game profile" bullets are ususally less pointed and therefore even the heavy 140' can be easily stabilized by 1:9.
Then, there is the question of loading a long (pointed) 140 gr bullet in the 260 case given that most 260's are not "long throated" like the 6.5 X 65 and therefore, the long bullet may protrude further into the case than some reloaders want.
I am still trying to find out the effect of spinning a bullet too fast (over-rotating). It seems that a fair amount of over rotation can be tolerated without adverse results unless the bullet is not concentric...and then the lack of concentricity is amplified. This would mean that 1:8 twist might over rotate a 107gr bullet and if it was not concentric...cause it to lose stability.
Then, there is the issue of velocity ... The higher the velocity, the faster the bullet spins. This may become a factor when muzzle velocities exceed 2800fps.
Well, I still haven't figured out the answer! In the end, it is testimonials from folks who actually have expeience with the twists and bullets that are most helpfull. Sometimes, there is just no substitute that has the credibility of real experience!