After spending most of the morning going through the many pages, here's my mom's very simple, but the popular recipe from many decades ago. My only twist is that added sliced sweet peppers to it, not for the taste but for those that "know they don't like" pickled eggs.
3 dozen large hard-boiled eggs, peeled
4 cups pickling vinegar
1 cup of water
1 cup of sugar
1Tbsl Pickling salt
2 tbsp pickling spice
Sliced onion
Red, yellow & green pepper wedges (optional)
Layer onion & eggs until the jar is packed full. May also add sweet peppers with the layers of onions for colour (and it helps that they taste good too!)
It's a pretty safe and true brine! Now, after scouring the many posts, I need to do some work of my own. I have tried to use smoke on this recipe in the past, it was disappointing. I think my mistake was doing the eggs in the shell which limits the amount of smoke the eggs can take on. They definitely take on the smokey colour, the flavour not so much. Looking at past recipes from the thread, I also find it ironic that this brine lacks garlic cloves. If you were to visit our home and be served almost any food - you would be challenged to find meat or preserves without garlic in it. The only one I can think of, if maybe Jean Pare's Million Dollar Relish (move over Bicks and Heinz you lose!)