Pietta vs Vaquero

nitorexpress: Re-fitting the transfer bar was a pretty easy job. Some careful polishing of its contact surfaces, that's about it. Gun right back in good form, again. I might add that for me, cowboy action shooting is just about as much fun as you can have with your boots still on, too!

I know quite a few fellow shooters, who also name their guns. "Barky". Good handle for a .44! The name fits. Your guns are in great condition. Mine, not so much. Externally, anyway. Holster wear over the years has taken its toll on the blueing. But, those Rugers still keep humming along. I see you've got a bit of wear showing on your ivory handled shooting iron. Adds a bit of character.

By the way, I like to fit my Vaqueros with either: Eagle Gunfighter grips. Or: Altamont grips. The stock Ruger wooden grips are very nice. But, the others just seem to fit my hands a bit better. Personal preference...nothing else.

I do know one shooter who regularly competes with a vintage 1892 Winchester, chambered in .32-20. Fun cartridge. I am also a big fan of the .38-40. I wish Miroku-Winchester or Uberti would make a run of these. Would buy one, in a heart beat. Became hooked, some years back.

An old neighbour and shooting companion of mine(Long gone now, but never forgotten), once owned an original 1873 Winchester rifle, chambered in .38-40. Came to him by way of his grandfather... who'd purchased the rifle new, in 1880. I'd heard of the caliber, but never shot one, up 'till then. Had previous experience with the .44-40, though.
The rifle was in original, well used but well cared-for condition. Right down to the neatly rolled-up bill of sale and segmented brass cleaning rod, stowed in the rifle's buttstock compartment. A carefully fitted, spring loaded trapdoor inset into the steel butt plate, kept everything safely stowed inside.

Anyway....after the first few shots....there was no turning back. Have dreamed about owning a '73, chambered in .38-40, ever since.

Al

ps: This past weekend, while discussing the toll Covid had taken on the sport of cowboy action here in Canada, over the last couple of years. One of my pards was jokingly asked whether he planned to hang up his spurs and quit cowboy action shooting, anytime soon. His reply: "Oh....about two months after I die!"
 
Last edited:
Where I shoot Cowboy Action there is a mix of Pietta, Uberti but dominated by New Vaqueros. While everyone seems happy with their choices as far as handling and shooting, the Rugers never break down. I use Vaqueros as main match guns and love them.

I would say for plinking either Pietta or Uberti but if you're going to run them hard in competition you'd definitely want Rugers.

Definitely go with .357/38 though, for,the economy and shooting ease.
 
Go with "Original" Vaqueros, I have them in .357, .44 Mag & .45 Colt. They are built like Russian T-34 tank. One of my .44's broke the transfer bar at 20,000 rds down range about 10 years ago. Simple fix and thousands of rds later no problems. My wife prefers SASS New Vaqueros, very nice ladies gun.

DSCN8133a.jpg
 
Awesome thread/read....as mentioned, we need more stuff like this. I feel a little more confident about my latest purchase, a couple of Pietta 45lc Peacemakers.
I've done a lot of reading and there's nothing bad to be said about the Vaqueros...however, I'm a newcomer to the CAS sport, and I could not justify a pair of Rugers to the
resident banker.....:cool::stirthepot2:
 
Bassmaster: The cure for your dilemma is to have the "resident banker" take up cowboy action shooting, too. Far easier to see the logic of gun choices, from a participant's view. Besides....it's a great way to spend some fun and enjoyable time together(Cowboy action is all that). Lots of couples do. As well as getting to know and share the experience with some really good folks. The sport can be pretty competitive, though. Plenty of the ladies are formidable shooters. So stay on your toes!
 
Back
Top Bottom