With the Vortex scopes if you tighten the rings any more then 15- 18 in. lbs. the scope will screw up. I've done that twice so now I try and stay right at 15 in. lbs. with Vortex
Please post what damage to the scope by this and if vortex covered it . I can't imagine
OP - please post if retourquing fixes problem , scope or rifle screws , or if indeed your scope got pooched with such minor use