RCBS 5-10 not zeroing.

Before you give up on it, there's one thing you can try.

Remove the magnets from the frame of the scale and be sure they're clean, nothing sticking to them, ferrous or otherwise.
Do the same with the recesses they sit in.

Pay attention when you're taking them out as to which way they're oriented, as in, which magnetic pole faces where.
Then re-assemble them and try it.

If it works, good. If it doesn't, play with changing the orientation of the magnetic poles. The previous owner may have had the scale apart and put them back wrong, if that's possible.

I have a 5-0-5 that did the same thing yours does. I tried everything you have, and finally removed the magnets and cleaned them. I didn't find any major smoking guns, but when I re-assembled the da*n thing it worked, and has ever since. Go figure.

A friend had a similar problem, he solved it by passing a ferrous item (I seem to recall he used a large screwdriver blade) back and forth in the scale slot between the magnets several times.

Magnetism is interesting stuff with a little bit of witchcraft mixed in, at least that's the way it is for me.

When you've nothing better to do, this is an interesting video on rare earth magnets and a chunk of copper pipe. I looked at this, and being a skeptic, had to try it for myself. It works! There are dozens of similar videos, I just picked this one.

https://youtu.be/NqdOyxJZj0U

The reason the copper blade and magnets dampens the movement of the beam is that the magnetic field resists the motion of the copper through it. If there's no motion, nothing happens. Same as a generator, which is a copper winding moving through a magnetic field.

The video in itself won't explain what's going on with your scale, nor will it explain how it's fixed if what I suggested works. At this point, you've not a lot to lose by trying it.

If it works again, I'd recommend removing the beam from the scale frame when you're not using it.
Copper isn't entirely anti-magnetic, just very low level. And, the blade on the scale is probably not 100% pure copper.
If it sits in the magnetic field long enough, it will be very slightly attracted.
 
I have heard of people washing the scale with soapy water and drying it off, then it’s back to normal. Don’t know if it was dirt or magnetic issues.

My 5-0-5, I calibrated it for a different pan, and added a piece of foam under the beam where it “ clanks down”. I think this will reduce wear on the knives. Other than blowing dust and cat hair of the blades before I use it, it’s been reliable. ( knock on wood )
 
So a really nice guy on here offered me a 10-10 for a great price and it’s already in the mail. I would still like to get my 5-10 looked at. Anybody on here able to tune or look at this scale and fix it? I could face time the person to show them what’s going on before shipping it.
 
Before you give up on it, there's one thing you can try.

Remove the magnets from the frame of the scale and be sure they're clean, nothing sticking to them, ferrous or otherwise.
Do the same with the recesses they sit in.

Pay attention when you're taking them out as to which way they're oriented, as in, which magnetic pole faces where.
Then re-assemble them and try it.

If it works, good. If it doesn't, play with changing the orientation of the magnetic poles. The previous owner may have had the scale apart and put them back wrong, if that's possible.

I have a 5-0-5 that did the same thing yours does. I tried everything you have, and finally removed the magnets and cleaned them. I didn't find any major smoking guns, but when I re-assembled the da*n thing it worked, and has ever since. Go figure.

A friend had a similar problem, he solved it by passing a ferrous item (I seem to recall he used a large screwdriver blade) back and forth in the scale slot between the magnets several times.

Magnetism is interesting stuff with a little bit of witchcraft mixed in, at least that's the way it is for me.

When you've nothing better to do, this is an interesting video on rare earth magnets and a chunk of copper pipe. I looked at this, and being a skeptic, had to try it for myself. It works! There are dozens of similar videos, I just picked this one.

https://youtu.be/NqdOyxJZj0U

The reason the copper blade and magnets dampens the movement of the beam is that the magnetic field resists the motion of the copper through it. If there's no motion, nothing happens. Same as a generator, which is a copper winding moving through a magnetic field.

The video in itself won't explain what's going on with your scale, nor will it explain how it's fixed if what I suggested works. At this point, you've not a lot to lose by trying it.

If it works again, I'd recommend removing the beam from the scale frame when you're not using it.
Copper isn't entirely anti-magnetic, just very low level. And, the blade on the scale is probably not 100% pure copper.
If it sits in the magnetic field long enough, it will be very slightly attracted.

From my work.
 
You can try the scale without the magnets installed. It won't settle quickly, but if it does eventually come to center reliably it's a magnetism issue, not a mechanical one.
 
So I went back at the scale tonight. I’m convinced the the knife edges on the centre pivot are out of alignment with each other. I’m going to contact RCBS and see if they can replace the knife edge piece on the beam. I scrubbed everything again. When trying without the magnets the problem still existed but not as dramatic.
 
Last edited:
Well…. I did it. I fixed the darn thing. It zeros every time. I took the knife edge out of the beam. Sharpened it nicely. Levelled my scale, put the knife back in, got the knife to the correct placement to read zero and put a tiny dab of super glue around the seam on each side sparingly. It goes to zero whether the pointer rises to zero or rests to zero.

I have a friends 10-10 here that is well used, dirty and it just works so dam good. I don’t know why my 5-10 was so finicky almost as finicky as a vintage slot car.

I put the 250gr check weight on my 5-10 and it read .05 grain short of 250 and hit that spot when the pointer creeped up or fell to it so I’m happy.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom