The problem with bad reviews is most of the time the guys writing the reviews have never had anything to do with the review their writing. People love to bad mouth things they don't have. If they see it and they don't like it, they will convince you why you shouldn't like it either. What are the odds of a pumpgun going off on it's own when you close the slide? While it could happen, it's probably not very likely. Of course I'm sure there will be a comment about that like "I know a guy who had that happen to him so your full of s**t" but I'll get over it. Actually, I saw somthing similar happen once with a rifle of mine. My friend was using my lever action .30-30 for the first time, he loaded the magazine and racked the action from the hip and the rifle went off. He swore it just went off on it's own and I may have been inclined to believe him if it wasn't for the fact I saw his finger in the triggergaurd when he closed the lever, discharging the rifle. He swears he didn't do that, but I saw it. Now if my friend started to tell his story, pretty soon everyone would know for a fact Marlin rifles are dangerous because the hammer can fall on a loaded round when cycling the action on it's own. Next there will be more guys who come out of the woodwork and say they had that happen too, and the next thing you know the rifles are obviously garbage and unsafe to use. Now I just cracked out one of my pumps and tried to get the trigger to pull on closing, I couldn't. You must release the trigger before it will fire on the second pull. however I've seen guys, especially when being cool and shooting from the hip both pulling back on the fore end and pushing foward on the gun at the same time. I tried that and sure enough, the gun would 'fire' and it would appear it was almost seamless as if the gun just went off. And if your not paying attention you could pull the trigger. How many times have you seen a guy grab a gun and when he does his finger is automatically on the trigger? I've preached it time and time again, unless you know for a fact that somebody has tried somthing, don't believe them. I could tell you I own a Ferrari and you would have little reason to doubt me, but I don't. But I could also tell you I'm not such a fan of Ferrari's so I'm constantly critisizing Ferrari based on nothing but my inexperiance and personal disdain that has zero relivance or credibility other then I just don't like them. (I'm being fasecious, I think Ferrari's are way cool) If pressed, the guys doing the biggest bashing wil almost always tell you they don't own one (whatever the topic may be) but they've heard enough stories...