Remington vs. Savage

G

grey

Regular
EE Expired
Rating - 100%
3   0   0
I want to add a reasonably priced, longer range, bolt action rifle to my collection. I have a couple of SKS's, and nice Norinco M305 in a Boyd's stock, but I want something that will be fun to target shoot at longer ranges -- 200 to 500 yards -- that would also be suitable for hunting. I have been looking at a couple of different guns, but I would love to hear from folks that know more than me what they think of my choices, or any other rifles that are possible more suitable. I want to stick to .308 to keep my ammo stocks consistent.

Specifically, I have been considering two Savage rifles:

10 FCP-K I like what I read about this rifle, particularly the "accustock" but I am concerned that it might be a bit heavy for hunting. It is also the most expensive of the rifles I have looked as so far.

10 FP-SR threaded Carbine .308 This also looks like an interesting rifle, with a heavy barrel and a reputation for good accuracy out of the box.

I have also looked at a couple of Remington rifles:

Model 700 Tactical SPS
Model 700 Tactical SPS AAC-SD

I think the main difference between the two is the second one is threaded for a muzzle brake or suppressor.

Given what I am trying to do, which is the best choice?

Thanks in advance for all opinions and suggestions.
 
ford Vs Chevy

both savage and remmington make good out of the box rifles, chances are one wont shoot better then the other. you could get an amzing shooter or nothing special from either company, both have a big after market following . find what fits you best and go from there
 
I would pick one of the savages. They are some of the most accurate rifles I have owned also at a good price point. I don't think it will be to heavy depends what kind of hunting you will be doing.
 
10 FCP-K is nice but has a decent weight. Not heavy enough to not take it hunting through, just a bit tricky to shoot standing up without any support. Very very accurate once you find the right ammo.
 
10/110 Predator Hunter Max 1

That would be my pick if you wanted something to do everything with a bit of a compromise all around. Get it in .260 Rem and you're laughing....

But you'll have to reload for it...
 
I have the savage 10 FCP-K and love it! great rifle and a tac driver forsure. You are right it is a heavy rifle to bushwack with. I pretty much use mine for target shooting only.
 
ultimate_monkey said:
ford Vs Chevy

both savage and remmington make good out of the box rifles, chances are one wont shoot better then the other. you could get an amzing shooter or nothing special from either company, both have a big after market following . find what fits you best and go from there
Click to expand...

Pretty much.

Both make some nice models and both turn out a bit of junk now and again.
 
I too agree that overall this is a ford vs chevy thing or basically just personal preference.

In my experience I have owned about 4 to 5 Rem 700 from 22-250, .223, and .308 all were fine rifles that shot well. My last one was a 5R milspec in .308 which I decided to trade in on a Savage 10 fcp-k in .308. Since then I have never wanted to go back to Rem. Not because they are not good, but just because in my personal experience I felt like the Savage had more to offer compared to the 5R I had. Ie: Fluted barrel, muzzle brake, adjustable trigger, floating bolt head, removeable mag, 3 position safety. Then if you want to broaden your horizons a bit and play around the Savage system allows an owner with a few basic tools to swap barrels and bolt faces to switch calibers if you want. Some don't like the accutrigger but I ended up really liking it so that was a bonus for me personally as well. By the way I too take it hunting. I have a good sling for the hike and still do not find it overly heavy when not slung, but I am just used to carrying heavy barrels as I don't own any sporters.

The main edge I would give to Rem is the availability of aftermarket stocks.

Still suggest you go touch and feel for yourself though as you can't go wrong with either so final decision might just be made by holding and seeing one for yourself.
 
Having owned the models you are looking at, by both companies I personally prefer the savage. But you should go out, try each one and see for yourself. Maybe someone near you has a model your interested in amd would allow you to try?
 
A lot of it will boil down to preference, as others have stated. Generally speaking, from what I've seen the Savage rifles tend to be more accurate out of the box. If it is something that you are going to want to trick out with every imaginable option, the Rem. might be the way to go. There are some features of the Savage rifles that I find much more convenient such as the barrel is removable by the user with basic tools and knowledge. If you want an oversized/different bolt handle it is as simple as removing the screw at the rear of the bolt assembly and putting a new handle on. The accu-trigger, while some people dislike it, is very nice IMO and a great factory trigger. The fact that they have detachable magazines is a big plus for me, much more convenient while hunting to pop your magazine in when you are ready to shoot.
 
I have owned both, both did the job, but I I just have savages now. There quality control seems to be better, they out shoot the Remy's I have owned. Most work can be done without a smith. The floating bolt head seems helps as well, blueprinting and truing seems like a waste on a savage. Triggers are decent over Remington. The only advantage I would really give Remington's is the availability of aftermarket parts, but savage is quickly catching up in that department. Winchesters are the is smoothest of the bolt action i have used though, I would love a decent pre 64 win!
 
10 FCPK is great for hunting... and groups better then my friend 700 varmint

374087_10150438280963552_1746199808_n.jpg
 
I have owned both, I like the 700 actions better, but the savage factory rifles have generally been more accurate. Savage has definitely figured out how to make decent factory barrels.
 
I have the Savage FLCP-K..308....The (L) stands for left handed. Yes, I feel the shame. Excellent rifle! I also have the Remy 700 SDS tactical, in 223. Lighter rifle trigger is good, but not as nice as the accutrigger on the Savage. IMO.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom