S&W 5946 Vs STI Ranger Vs Glock 17

[RDevigne]

Thanks for all who helped out in making a choice. I ended up going with a CZ SP-01 Shadow. I've heard good things about it and even though its not a 1911, I have to say she's a pretty ###y peice. She will make a very nice addition to my collection. After I'm used to competing, I'll splurge and get either a .40 or .45 high end STI, Kimber or Springfield and go into standard division. I already have a few 1911 to keep me happy until I can get one.

Cheers

 

[sillymike]

If you want to shoot IPSC, I guess you have to play by the rule... so Glock or SP01 it would be.

But for just a fun range gun, I'd go with the Ranger. I 1911 in 9mm has been on my wish list for some time now...

 

[BC Mike]

Im torn, between these models, your help is needed !!!

S&W 5946 9mm
STI Ranger II 9mm
Glock 17 9mm

Ive read and read and read, what I need is people who shot these babies to chime in and tell me how it is and to slap some sense into me because if i keep going back and forth much longer, i think i might go insane


Thanks in advance

It's obvious you need both a 1911 style and one of the "other". Even I want a Glock and I don't even like them!, proving that insanity runs in the (shooting) family.

 

[ontgunner]

All these type of threads have a common thread (pun intended ).
This vs. Glock
That vs. Glock
The other thing vs. Glock
If Glock is the standard to which all other guns are compared...
BUY THE GLOCK!!

 

[RDevigne]

oh, I will buy a glock, there is no question , it's just in what order

 

[Dragoon]

...... if you want something that is competitive for IPSC, none of your choices are particularly competitive......

I beg your pardon? The IPSC Canada National Production Champions for 2002, 2004 and 2006 all shot Glocks. (2003 was a Beretta and 2005 was a CZ) I'd say that's pretty competitive.......