All good points, but the best point is, to each his own.
A have Uberti Cattleman, Ruger Vaquero's and New Ruger Vaqueros's all in 45 Colt - 7.5". (Stainless and blued versions)
To my, each his own (if that makes sense) are the Ruger Vaqueros.
They just fit me better and I shoot them better.
The others slide around in my bear paws.
I would also say that the Rugers are tougher in the long haul.