Same or not?
- Thread starter rimfire458
- Start date
Ardent
CGN Ultra frequent flyer
The more I look at this the more confused I am, can't lie. The perspective on the shot deer is terrible. The brow tines certainly look like the same deer, the perspective on the shot deer really skews everything, I'm forced to say yep it is.
- Location
- West Quebec
Good catch...sharp eye
I'm not quite understanding. Forgive my ignorance. Are You saying that one of the night pics is the same as the dead one and one is not? I'm guessing You're saying the one facing the camera is not. Please explain why so a meat head such as I can grasp. Not trying to be a wise guy
The one laying at rest in the trailer is not in my opinion the same deer as in the game cameras. I am going partly by the R tine first up from the brow tine. that R tine has a wow in it which is not visible in the trailer deer. Also the L brow tine on the trailer deer is higher than the R in the first game camera picture this it is the opposite, and the L main beam tines on the trailer deer do no not match the game camera deer.
It wouldn't matter to me as I would be thrilled to have taken either one, both very nice bucks. Had a pair like that make an appearance twice on my front lawn in Sept. Haven't seen hide nor hair of them since on any of my game cameras.
It wouldn't matter to me as I would be thrilled to have taken either one, both very nice bucks. Had a pair like that make an appearance twice on my front lawn in Sept. Haven't seen hide nor hair of them since on any of my game cameras.
I think the question was, "Is the dead deer in the trail cam pictures."
In the first dark picture the deer is too indistinct to make a call, but it looks smaller with smaller antlers.
The antlers on the second deer on the trail cam is very much like the dead deer, but not it.
Look at the tip end of the left main beam. A point is close to a V with the main beam.
Now look at the one in the picture and the point near the tip of the left main beam is an inch or two back from the tip of the main beam.
BigUglyMan
CGN Ultra frequent flyer
- Location
- New Scotland
I say no.
And to further add the one on the trailer has different colour eyes than the trail camera deer.
Well the "EYE"S have it LOL.
Actually I think they are the same. How I don't know with them looking so different. But I was getting these trail cam pics by the dozen and even more I just didn't post. If there's 10 pics their all different. I hung the trail camera right from the time the big guy went down till two days ago and nothing over 6 points. I'm afraid believe it or not their all the same bird. The theme here is that what You see on trail cam and what You really see at the end may not be the same. This one ties them all together
Last edited:
I think they are the same deer...I had the same thing this fall...Got a nice 8 pointer on Camera...shot a nice 8 pointer, which I feel is same deer...I have pics, but am unable to post them...if anybody cares to...I will forward them by email...deerdr@nbcsmail.com Respectfully. HOWEVER often bucks sired by same father look remarkably similar.
You nailed it
